Thanks for the thoughtful post. I agree with most of your points, particularly regarding the push-pull now between the allure of vintage-type gear and the new stuff. My main amp is the Ampeg V-4B reissue, which is 1/3 lighter, so I guess that's a little of both.This is worthy of a longer post. I think there is a strong tendency for every generation to wear those rose-colored glasses (dunno if it's particularly stronger in us boomers, tho' you might have a point). To me, the more interesting thing concerning the original post is the list of present day hardware don'ts - and that an awful lot of good music was made in spite of our past sins. We can question whether it's the best, but it was pretty darned good. We got away with technological murder!
I'm as guilty as the next person but it seems to me a lot of us possess quite a few hardware / technology / convenience fetishes these days. I vacillate between luxuriating in the wealth of bass playing goodies available to me and on the other hand wanting to be a stone Luddite. By virtue of having too much disposable income, I think I've come down on the side of "golly-gee-whiz that new amp sure looks to be a fine thing, let's give it a whirl". But I could certainly stand to do a whole lot more plain ol' music making.
Certainly, a lot of great music was made back then. I think what gets overlooked is that "we" got away with a lot of hardware don'ts because live recording gear, and playback equipment, was for the most part much lower-fi than it is today. A lot fewer performances were recorded at all, too.
My initial post was strongly worded because of what seems to be the constant drumbeat on TB by many of my fellow Boomers about how all or most music was great then and it basically all sucks today--edited to add, or sometimes it's argued that everything after the '80s, or everything after 1975 or so, stinks too. I think many have lost the open-mindedness they were celebrated for back in the day. Maybe future generations will act similarly. But there are so many of us Boomers (thus the term!) right now saying this kind of thing.
It's a busy day at work and we have company at home, I'll respond to others when I get a chance.
Last edited:
