Just for the record, I was doing some general maintenance on a number of my birds today (oiling fretboards, wiping down hardware, cleaning bodies, tuning and adjusting setups as needed) and ended up playing eleven birds back to back with a Kenny Wayne Shepherd Blue on Black recording. Some interesting observations - namely that price has a lot less to do with how nice a bass sounds than most people would think, string selections can make or break a great bass, and feel is every bit as important as sound.
First place
Lull Petersson bass is an absolute monster - low mids to die for, super light weight, fast neck. Definitely in the top tier I played today.
North ThunderCaster - my god, this thing will tear buildings down. Right there with the Lull on sound, body is heavy though.
Purple Sparkle ‘64 Eppi - right out of the box this thing has a massive bang for the buck, sounds every bit as good as the Lull as well.
Capped Goth - just as good as the three above but with a $300 all in price
Second place
North ‘66 Tribute NR - equipped with first run 760ProBuckers, sounds great but not the girth or depth of the ‘64 Eppi
Eppi VP first run - sweet but not as sweet as the Purple sparkle in sound
Gibson 21 NR Reissue - a wonderful player, love the neck profile on this thing, creamy lows, solid all around bass
Third place (and still damn good basses)
FrankenGoth - the Aggie preamp and BART humbuckers really shine, lots of tonal options
Pink Sparkle Acasia - similar to the bass above, the East preamp and Nordstrand combo is a tone monster, but a bit more sterile
White BaCH - dual ChinaBuckers sound great, punch and grind, heavy bass, nice neck
Blue BaCH - dual Artec pickups sound nearly as good, lighter weight bass, super thin fast neck