I'd probably feel differently if bass hadda been my first instrument... but I love 'em all! The P-bass is responsible for a hugely significant portion of rock & roll history. It is a true "foundation". I love the midrangy "honk" of a Jazz bass. It doesn't belong
everywhere... but hey... neither do I. I think there's room for
all the different basses... but I would use them more like some people use effects pedals. My pickier than hell left hand and my wallet both render that scenario unrealistic. When I finally got to spend some time with a T-bird in my hands... so many mysteries were solved. I finally found what made that snarl that I'd been hearing and loving for so many years (long before I started playing bass). I'd always thought that it had more to do with the amps they were using, than the bass itself. Now... I know... and now I have that, and it makes me smile! It doesn't make me like the others any less. What makes me like them less, are wafer thin necks, and having only one pickup... but I still love the sounds they produce. Now in terms of aesthetics... I've been "tetched". If it don't have soap bars of some sort... it just looks wimpy and wrong (my heart breaks a little every time I see one of those Epi NRs). I think the Cataldo RR is the stone cold sexiest bass that has ever been built... and it's his twist on a Jazz bass.
View attachment 1189633
I brought this up, just to illustrate my point. It's not an "either/or" situation for me. The two worlds can coexist and intermingle. In fact... I like it when they do! It brings uniqueness and versatility with it!