TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
^ This IS good! I got through about 6 pages and saw the flame war setting up but was out of popcorn so jumped to the last page...Sigh.. I dont even want to look through this thread
49% people who dont have fenders, and dont have the ears or knowledge to bash them, but do
49% fender fans who dont believe another bass exists
2% amused lurkers who'd love a fresh Pbass as much as a new roscoe
WHY DONT YOU PEOPLE SHUT UP AND GO PRACTICE
Sigh.. I dont even want to look through this thread
49% people who dont have fenders, and dont have the ears or knowledge to bash them, but do
49% fender fans who dont believe another bass exists
2% amused lurkers who'd love a fresh Pbass as much as a new roscoe
WHY DONT YOU PEOPLE SHUT UP AND GO PRACTICE

.....Fender is what people play when they don't don't want to be unique, and want to sound like everyone else.
Yes, I own a P bass, and I had to try almost a dozen before I found one I could even consider taking home.

To Me, Fender Is................
Not for me. I've owned three. A respectful No, Thank you.
chadds said:Roscoe gets mentioned, out of all other makers, why?
Cause their own tagline says, "a P-bass that sounds like a Steinway".
Gotta have that.
John D said:Jamerson, Dunn, Jaco...man this list could go on all night and every player mentioned would be unique in the field. Nice try.![]()
Love my SG500 tooI'm yet to play any bass by any manufacterer that is perfect from factory.
For instance I have never played any fretted bass that didn't have the frets sticking out a bit further than a luthier would have them.
I have two electric basses right now, an Ibanez soundgear and a Fender Highway One. For $550 Ibanez gives you a thinner smoother neck that is five piece wenge/bubinga, bartolini pickups, three band active eq, a mahogony body, all in a bass that is roughly five pounds. For $1000 bucks Fender will give you a slab of wood, a cheap bridge and some cheap passive pickups that they know you are going to replace as soon as you get it home.
That being said a Fender Jazz was the first bass I bought and I don't intend on ever being without one. I know there has been plenty of inovations since Leo invented it but sometimes you want to play the original, the classic, and that is what Fender is for, when you want to play a Fender.![]()