tadawson said:I dunno . . . I can't recall my reference exactly, but I am an EE by degree, and definitely have seen a credible reference to rectifiers that were designed for a certain filter capacitance failing if the filters are made too large. Not due to oscillation or anything long term like that, but rather due to the surge currents when the caps charge when the amp is first powered up. A diode can carry it's rated current forever, but powerup surge is many orders of magnitude higher than that, and diodes can only carry their surge rating for very short periods, and increased capacitance will cause both the duration and magnitude of the initial powerup surge to increase . . . If the diodes were not very overrated to start with, it CAN cause failures . . . .
Now, having said that, please recognize that this does NOT mean that I agree with a lot of the other meritless crap that has come from seamonkey . . . I am just agreeing on this ONE point . . . .
- Tim
I don't disagree that it CAN happen at all, just that the amount of increase required to make it happen is going to be so big that it would be ridiculous. Inrush surge is a very real phenomemon. I know that, and I'm not disputing it. My Peavey Classic 400 sometimes trips my house breaker at power up. Shrimp-boy makes it sound as though ANY increase at all will immediately result in power supply problems and he used unlrealistic/phony figures for power supply capacitance to try and shore up his "arguement."
The other point I was making about oscillation was that with an increase in filtering, long before a rectifier would be overdrawn, the extra damping of the power supply would cause problems with the output section itself.