I've really enjoyed this thread. (And ones similar to it.) It's easy to take for granted just how many P bass oriented choices we have, and it's brought into focus in discussions like this.
Squier, Classic Vibe, MIM Fenders, CIJ Fenders, MIA Fenders, AVRI, Custom Shop, Fender Design Experience.
And this doesn't even address P type basses by Lakland, Sadowsky, Lull, Nash, Warmoth, etc.
Ash, Alder, Exotic hardwoods, chambered bodies or solid. Active electronics or passive. Mass produced pickups or Boutique. Vintage style hardware or High Tech state-of-the-art. Nitro laquer or poly. Maple, Rosewood, Ebony or Padauk fretboard. Nickel or Stainless Steel frets. Black, White, Mint, Parchmant, Mother-of-toilet-seat, or Tort pickguards. You know what I think? I think this is a pretty good time to be in the market for a P bass.
(And if Fender ever decides to bring back the '51 P/ '68 Tele, I'll ask you, "Blonde, Sunburst or Black?")