Were you dead before you were born (or conceived)?

[Tituscrow]

Not alive = dead.

No longer alive = dead
Not yet alive =/= dead

 

[mongo2]

Not alive = dead.

Incorrect.

No longer alive = dead
Not yet alive =/= dead

Correct.

 

[Munjibunga]

Incorrect.



Correct.

Thanks for giving us the definitive opinion.

 

[macaroni tony]

I still like explaining to everyone that when we are conceived we are ALL proto-female, well at least during the first six weeks anyway.

There is no female hormone to trigger a female infant, but after 6 weeks testosterone is released to form a male infant.

That's why men have hairy man nipples.

speak for yourself my nipsies are smooooooove

 

[UncleFluffy]

Not alive = dead.

2+2 =/= 3 therefore 2+2 = 5 ?

Maybe there are other options.

 

[Tituscrow]

speak for yourself my nipsies are smooooooove

So I've heard

 

[geeza]

speak for yourself my nipsies are smooooooove

No pics, no smooove... uhhhh, never mind.

 

[macaroni tony]

aw, and I had em loaded up and ready to go

 

[MatticusMania]

Of all the threads you could of necroed you chose this one?

That was the classiest ressurection of all time. OF. ALL. TIME.

 

[mongo2]

Thanks for giving us the definitive opinion.

Not opinion, fact. And you're welcome.

 

[Ziltoid]

That was the classiest ressurection of all time. OF. ALL. TIME.

Meh. I didn't miss this thread. AT. ALL.

 

[RED J]

From dust you came, to dust you will return.

 

[geeza]

^ needs to dust more often.

 

[two fingers]

Question is meaningless. Predicates have to have objects to apply to. There was no "me" to have the property of "dead" or "not-dead".

(That in itself doesn't exclude the idea of a pre-existing "soul", as "part of me" is not "me").

UncleFluffy must know what he's talking about because of all the quotation marks and junk....... and uh..... stuff.

I think there is no term for before we are here, other than "before we are here" of course. So, I'm in the not dead before birth camp.

(Now those are some words I never thought I would string into sentences.)

 

[Munjibunga]

Not opinion, fact. And you're welcome.

Fact in whose opinion?

 

[UncleFluffy]

UncleFluffy must know what he's talking about

even a stopped clock ...

 

[eyeballkid]

I was only right once today, and it was when I admitted I was wrong.
damn.

 

[ThatBassBoy]

You did exist before you were born.

First in an orange tree.

Than your father's balls.

Every atom in our bodies existed way before we were born.We are actually made of stardust.Poetic science FTW!

What makes me up existed prior, but me, as a whole, me as a human, never existed. Think of humans as a smoothie, the smoothie did not exist, but the ingredients such as strawberries, bananas, milk, and yogurt, did exist.

 

[jmercer91]

What makes me up existed prior, but me, as a whole, me as a human, never existed. Think of humans as a smoothie, the smoothie did not exist, but the ingredients such as strawberries, bananas, milk, and yogurt, did exist.

Blech! I'd never drink a human flavored smoothie!!!

 

[Munjibunga]

UncleFluffy must know what he's talking about because of all the quotation marks and junk....... and uh..... stuff.

I think there is no term for before we are here, other than "before we are here" of course. So, I'm in the not dead before birth camp.

(Now those are some words I never thought I would string into sentences.)

Dead, dead, dead, I say. Dead.