• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What is your favorite Genesis song?

Since it was brought up....

Hairless Heart (I bet nobody remembers this one!)
The Chamber Of 32 Doors
Back In N.Y.C.

Firth Of Fifth
Supper's Ready
The Return Of The Giant Hogweed

Prog rock is very hip at the moment apparently. It's the second "what's your favorite: prog" I answer today!
 
Alvaro Martín Gómez A.;7923528 said:
+1. I definitely hate post-Gabriel Genesis, but love almost everything from the Gabriel + Hackett era. Just to mention the first song that popped up in my head, I'd say "Watcher Of The Skies".
return of the giant hogweed from the live album comes to mind.........phil collins era genesis was like something so syrupy sweet it makes your teeth hurt
 
Watcher of the Skies is my favorite, mostly because the band I was in during the mid-70s did a very credible rendition of it. In bars, no less! The fact that it was generally well-received in those kind of venues says something about the tastes of the listening public at the time.
 
Undoubtedly No Reply at All. Sick bassline from Rutheford. Phil Collin's vocals are awesome (as usual). Great horn stuff (even though the horns aren't real.) Catchy, complex, poppy enough for mainstream, rock enough to be really enjoyable. Prog enough to be difficult to learn and play. (thus fun to learn or play :D) .
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlc1976
For me, it's The Musical Box.

Reminds me of a true story. The scene: My then three year old boy in the car seat behind his Mom and I. He hears an intro.
"MoooooMMMMM! Wouder!!! Wow-der!!!!"
She turns it up a little.
"No! Wow-der!!"
She turns it up. It's quite loud. His head is nodding. He mumbles the verse....then...

"And da Wam, wies down, on BWOOOAARDWAYYYY!!!!"

Bless.
 
I do like the Phil Collins Genesis. I thought they brought a really quirky, wonderful musicianship to rock/pop music. And..this was back before you had to be pretty and 19 to be popular.

Probably my favorite albums are Abacab, Genesis, Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance. I do like Duke as well.

Amen. It's difficult to believe my all time fave, Turn it on Again, was a such huge radio hit. Same w/Abacab; it's so damn musical while still being pop. There's just so much energy and intensity w/o the sillyness you see in today's pop.
 
Undoubtedly No Reply at All. Sick bassline from Rutheford. Phil Collin's vocals are awesome (as usual). Great horn stuff (even though the horns aren't real.) Catchy, complex, poppy enough for mainstream, rock enough to be really enjoyable. Prog enough to be difficult to learn and play. (thus fun to learn or play :D) .

Actually the horns are real. They were arranged by Earth, Wind & Fire's Thomas Washington and played by EWF's horn section. :-)