Two coats on the P-bass body today:
I laid it on a little heavy so there are some runs but it's just going to get sanded completely back anyway. These first few coats are just filling grain. As per @Bruce Johnson 's suggestion, I'm using Minwax Oil-Modified wipe on poly for this. It was a little heartbreaking to sand that first coat all the way back to wood but that's just how this'll go until the grain is filled up. I'm sanding back with 220 now but I'll use smaller grits and thinner applications when I start the surface coats. I expect it to take 5 or six coats to fill the grain before I can start building coats on the surface. Luckily it dries really fast but I won't have much free time for a while anyway so this will be 2 coats at a time for weeks.
I also found a pickguard with the right hole pattern:
A gift from a friend at a local music store, it was glumped with dirt and heavily scratched up. I wet sanded it back through all the grits of Micro-Mesh, then Novus, then regular guitar polish. There are still micro scratches but it's shiny and that seems about right to me for a '75 P-bass. I already put about two hours of sanding into this "free" pickguard and I decided that good enough really is good enough sometimes.
I laid it on a little heavy so there are some runs but it's just going to get sanded completely back anyway. These first few coats are just filling grain. As per @Bruce Johnson 's suggestion, I'm using Minwax Oil-Modified wipe on poly for this. It was a little heartbreaking to sand that first coat all the way back to wood but that's just how this'll go until the grain is filled up. I'm sanding back with 220 now but I'll use smaller grits and thinner applications when I start the surface coats. I expect it to take 5 or six coats to fill the grain before I can start building coats on the surface. Luckily it dries really fast but I won't have much free time for a while anyway so this will be 2 coats at a time for weeks.
I also found a pickguard with the right hole pattern:
A gift from a friend at a local music store, it was glumped with dirt and heavily scratched up. I wet sanded it back through all the grits of Micro-Mesh, then Novus, then regular guitar polish. There are still micro scratches but it's shiny and that seems about right to me for a '75 P-bass. I already put about two hours of sanding into this "free" pickguard and I decided that good enough really is good enough sometimes.



