• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What's your view on this?

I found my playing bass has definitely incremented my treble guitar EXP. And so vice versa. I also carry about a harmonica, and eventually I wanna learn to play the organ/clavinet. Being a musician means using all the tools at your disposal to bring out the creativity.
 
I learned to play guitar during recovery from an injury that prevented me from playing bass. At the time, bass was all I could play, but I soon found that playing guitar gave me a different perspective on what else is going on in a rhythm section.

That said, bass is my first and only love, and still the only instrument that truly draws me.
 
I started on piano, but switched to guitar so girls would talk to me (edited for TB). Switched to bass a couple years later to audition for a "real" band. Learned enough on a drum kit to write songs. If anybody asks, I'm a bassist. I don't like talking to people (stranger danger), so this is the easiest way to end a conversation.
 
I've noticed an increasing trend towards multi-instrumentalism in touring bands largely because of forced downsizing. Within certain circles a player will be more valuable if he is an average player on more than one instrument than an above-average player on one instrument.
 
I don't think a person has to learn new instruments to know the instrument. Let me put it this way, there are musicians that compose for symphonies. That doesn't mean that person has to know how to play every instrument: trumpet, tuba, cello, violin, bass drum, triangle, etc. That person just needs to know how each instrument sounds, their ranges and limitations, and how they interact.

For most people in this forum, you don't have to play drums, guitar, nor keyboard, but it's good to have a sense of how they interact with you and vice versa to maintain rhythm and sonic space.

The one thing I have learned that is even more important than learning another instrument (if you don't care to), it's how to project sound in any given venue. You don't have to be a trained sound-engineer, but at least understand how to get the best end-result sound for your audience.
--

As far as learning guitar, if you don't want to, that's fine. It certainly won't make you a worse musician unless you're purposely learning just to fail. At the very least you're learning how chords are formed on a fretboard.

It's easy for me to write these opinions, I guess, because I am a multi-instrumentalist that composes once in a while. If I do write drum parts, I just have to remember not to compose anything that's physically impossible for one drummer like hitting 5 cymbals, 2 toms, and 3 snares at the same time.
 
I found playing with better musicians than I they encouraged me to learn piano to understand theory and solo with a purpose rather than noodling endlessly in modes without rhyme or reason. I thought it better to learn guitar chords as it was a better reference to my own fingerboard. Knowing the chords and chord tones helps me so much writing better bass lines and also made me realise I don't know enough about theory even after a few years of lessons to solo period. :crying:
 
Big change this will turn out to nothing, but I have to ask you this : what is your view on people who only play one instrument? I know some people who play several instruments, and I know some people who only one instrument.

I know it can help you with creating your own music if you play on several instruments, but is it necessary to play on several instruments? Personally I'm fine with bass guitar, though I'm itching to learn how to play drums and guitar. But even if I won't learn how to play them, I'm fine.

Anything wrong with that?

I don't think it matters at all. Do whatever the heck you wan to do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas Kievit
but is it necessary to play on several instruments?

Not necessary at all unless you just want to. I'm probably most competent on bass, but play most brass and woodwinds, piano, and guitar well enough to double on them when needed, and I tend to think of myself as "jack of all trades, master of none". Playing other instruments can give you some more insight into how music really works since you won't have the same visual patterns to use that a fretboard gives you, but if bass makes you happy, don't feel you have to learn others and don't for a minute think that anyone will think less of you for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas Kievit