Something I find amusing on a social forum site like TB are the people who provide profile information, but then block who is allowed to see it.
maybe someone who does that will respond: why? what's the reasoning?
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Something I find amusing on a social forum site like TB are the people who provide profile information, but then block who is allowed to see it.
My name is Mantis Tobaggan.
I play surf music and have been playing 13s.Just the man I wanted to see regarding g*itar strings. Any six string tips? I'm looking to restring a strat and a double humbucker guitar, both with something other than steel round tens if you've got a suggestion.
Let’s have some fun with this and take it a step further…
Consider this for a moment. Since you can’t take a person’s name or likeness and use it for commercial purposes without obtaining permission and paying compensation, the same reasoning should be applied to your personal information. If someone is making money off of selling the information they collected about you, then you should be entitled to some form of compensation for it.
Maybe we could create and register with a personal information licensing agency and anyone who wanted to use the data our activities generated would have to go through this agency to use it?
I know they’ll argue they “anonymize” our data before they sell it. But how is that really any different than taking your name off a book you wrote and then turning around and selling to someone without paying you a royalty? Sure. They’ll tell you targeting ads works to your benefit. But isn't that just another example of saying they’re “paying” you with “exposure” instead of cash?
Obviously they feel your data is valuable. Check out the prices of some “selected customer” contact lists they sell.
Hey Big Data Collector! Where’s our seat at the table? And how about passing us a piece of that pie while you’re at it!
![]()
It's unlikely to be personal, and you'd be surprised at how much identifying information you let slip. One little bit by itself isn't much, but think of them as snowflakes that can be collected by a team who build snowballs.
One time back in the 90's I went to meet up with some guys at a parking lot near a freeway in Tacoma so they could lead me to where the audition was. I had sat there waiting in my car for about 10 minutes and someone tried to open the passenger door and get in my car. I didn't immediately connect the dots, but when the dude from the band failed to show up I realized someone tried to carjack me and I inadvertently foiled their plan by having my passenger door locked.
That was the incident that sparked my paranoia.
Not really. I'm pretty tech savvy, since I started with web development in the mid 90's. I'm not the gal that opens the "happy birthday" email and clicks on the link. I'm not the gal that does the Facebook quiz about my mother's mother's maiden name. There's a lot I don't give up.
If you are at all halfway smart about it, you can divulge information appropriately without giving away the store. I cut my teeth on USENET. I've been in online brawls with hackers who've never managed to get anything more from me than an email address which gives them nothing at all unless I'm stupid enough to believe in the Nigerian prince or click an infected link. Really, we're in control of a lot. We just need to be smart about it.
Really, we're in control of a lot. We just need to be smart about it.
Addresses have been in phone books for decades. It’s hardly an issue.It's impossible to have a home business and not be locatable on the internet in about 30 seconds. I found every address I've lived at, my phone number, etc in about that.
Addresses have been in phone books for decades. It’s hardly an issue.
As for the post above? I already told you that I’m not so important that the government needs to waste precious talent tracking my every move. Hate to break it to you but neither are you.
That genie is long out of its bottle.
No worries. I was addressing two things in one post. Agreed with yoursSorry, wasn't trying to argue. Peace.
like the way you think.....i thinkIf I have a question I will ad enough details for you to provide an answer.
IMHO big brother will ultimately turn out to be NGOs because enough people are sufficiently paranoid to limit the government to some degree. In contrast, my impression is we have given essentially unrestricted access of our data to NGOs.
The part that bothers me is that pretty much nothing is being done to protect us, and actually the system advocates for unrestricted access and unlimited usage of big data because enterprising entities can use the data over and over again to make money. Unfortunately they don't seem to consider how sophisticated data collection and compilation has become, and how much of a threat big data poses to individuals or society at large.
So not only do I not populate my profile with personal info, I also worry about some of the personal info I have shared about my life that could potentially be data mined and somehow leveraged against me.
Perhaps you think I am paranoid, but just because I am paranoid does not mean people are not out to get me.
And it went up to 11, right?Don’t have it anymore. Lol! But yes it was a 9/10 cab.![]()
Never got that far! Monstrous! Lol!And it went up to 11, right?
HEY! Wait a minute … You better stand back, buster."
They'd work more for my benefit if they analysed my recent viewing and suggested related items I might be interested in. Instead of showing me adds for items I've viewed while researching them and either bought or decided against buying.They’ll tell you targeting ads works to your benefit.
I prefer not to live by associations I’ve had in the past that didn’t represent me accurately. By that I mean I’ve worked with well known people who’s music is not what I’m about. I rode the tour bus and played the way they wanted me to. Social media is chock full of assumptions and knee jerk/hair trigger responses so I provide a blank page as far as my work history goes to try and minimise that.TL;DR --- while there are good reasons not to share some things on your information page, why not share enough to be helpful to others who may want to be helpful to you, or to give advice to you!?
POV: when i actually joined the TB party = i didn't know any better so i filled out my information page with what i thought was enough info to get me going. (i don't think i've changed anything since then --- maybe i should?)
i didn't look at other's information pages (i mean: "why?") until i began to realize that knowing at least a little bit about the OP/poster could be helpful in giving a response (context). also: some of us have avatars/info present every time we post, while others 'reveal' nothing about themselves except what can be gleaned from a posting (often difficult, sometimes impossible). i don't think i/we need a lot of info: just the basics!
e.g.
- gender
- general location (country, part of the country)
- age or age group
- music: general experience, if any
- music we like/play
not knowing anything about another member can make it difficult to:
- give age/gender-appropriate feedback
- give location-appropriate feedback
- empathize
- care
- other reasons: explain your own!
FWIW: i've mentioned this 'issue' in a couple of threads and others have occasionally posted similar thoughts re: the lack of info on a member's information page! i'm curious about the reasons why some folks don't share some info/context.
in advance of your vote and/or your feedback, thanks!
Would that the big data genie had the charm and that “little middle” Barbara Eden was so famous for.
It would have at least been some consolation.![]()