TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
my point was the four is still best for all genre's.
Why? are you a purest not to own or use a four-string bass?

my point was the four is still best for all genre's
13 is enough for Jean. And 12 is enough for Garry Goodman.
And Warr Guitars are enough for how many people?
Most people here can make good music with a 4-string bass. Some people just make even better music with more strings. If they pay for it, sound good with it, and don't pressure you to use one, what on earth do you have a problem with?
![]()
Jeff Berlin: "Five string basses won't make you a better player."
Why on earth do I have a problem?
I'm illustrating the flipside of the Jaco thing.![]()
Anyone doing magic tricks with a cat must have a problem of some sort or other... Don't ja think?
Peace...![]()
Why on earth do I have a problem?
I'm illustrating the flipside of the Jaco thing.![]()
My apologies. I switched my audience without saying I was.
YEs i know, can't you read??? they have more than 4 strings but they are more often seen in fours (and many of teir hits are in fours). read it again. and by the way this is not a competition. and nobody argued on which tools to use, for obvious reasons, that there are different tools for different purposes as well as basses for different songs in which they are needed. my point was the four is still best for all genre's.
Why? are you a purest not to own or use a four-string bass?
this is not a competition.
<snip>
the four is still best for all genre's.

For all genres? Or for all the genres that you play/listen to?
This post delivers.
On a more serious note I tend to very defensive about my 9. And why shouldn't I be? I spent a few thousand dollars, and 13 months waiting for it....only to spend the last two years getting a firm enough of a grasp to play the thing just as well as my 5's. I used to own a Fodera AJ 6 and was subject to the "Fodera's aint' worth the money....Fodera's are all flash....blah blah blah." Yeah, ya know I did pay too much for it but it was MY decision, NOT yours or anyone elses. Shut yer trap. And no....I'm not rich, I'm a therapist at a mental health center...social work tends not to pay the bills too well. I just don't understand the rationale behind thrashing ERB'ers.
That's like saying "Hey man, your Dodge Viper sucks cause it's too fast."
Really? You sure about that? If you're gonna dog me for having a custom 9 then ya better be ready for me to slam you for playing a POS 4 string that you bought from a garage sale. If you don't want to get it back in the face, you better not throw it at me in the first place.
I get a little tired of the ERB'ers around here taking it on the chin (with the exception of John Turner) and sulking away just to help maintain the gentle balance that is TB. Screw that. Any 4 string purist that tries to lecture me is going to get an earfull of illogical nonsense and insults. Why? Cause that's how I roll.
There......there's my 2 cents. And yes......it delivers.