There you go.
You'll just have to take my word that those websites are chock full of chords/tab that are simplified, inaccurate, or just plain wrong.
I guess so.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
WHy is so much tab wrong?
- Thread starter glocke1
- Start date
There you go.
You'll just have to take my word that those websites are chock full of chords/tab that are simplified, inaccurate, or just plain wrong.
I guess so.
I definitely see that being a common scenario, but that doesn't sound like the scenario this thread was created around.
With all this tab bashing, it makes me feel better about not using it anymore and trying to learn music. Although the GP I play with has been playing by ear for many years now, and I often wonder if what he's playing is correct, not that I care, I'm still learning a lot from him.
Interesting thread. I guess bassists are less community oriented than computer scientists...
Scientists only have journal representatives coming after them when they overshare. A musician who puts accurate tab up will have music industry lawyers tracking him down! Those guys are pure evil!
Good point about those lawyers, I think. But apart from that I do not see the difference between contributing to Wikipedia and contributing to a bass tab.
I can also track down a basstrack to an extent, but sometimes it it tedious work. The bass is sometimes in the background of the music, and then it takes some work to hear what is going on. To get a quick start on cover songs, I think chords or tabs can help, even if there are some mistakes in the transciption.
I can also track down a basstrack to an extent, but sometimes it it tedious work. The bass is sometimes in the background of the music, and then it takes some work to hear what is going on. To get a quick start on cover songs, I think chords or tabs can help, even if there are some mistakes in the transciption.
- Jan 27, 2010
- 4,141
- 471
- Disclosures
- Endorsing Artist: Genz Benz Amplification
I'll sometimes look on ultimate guitar if I'm sitting around playing acoustic guitar, or if I get a request for a tune I don't know at a gig. Sometimes they're right, but most of them have huge errors, like Am instead of Em...
The people that rush to put that stuff up are often just learning themselves, and to their ear it sounds close enough.
The people that rush to put that stuff up are often just learning themselves, and to their ear it sounds close enough.
Hey, maybe error filled tab is a music industry conspiracy!
Skilled transcribers are POSING on the Internet as Ibanez geo playing 15-year-olds and INTENTIONALLY besmirching the good name and integrity of tab!
Just to point out one thing:
Chords written for guitar is often written based on the use of a capo. Those confuse us bassists (who never use capo).
Chords written for guitar is often written based on the use of a capo. Those confuse us bassists (who never use capo).
What do you expect for free? If I can tell it's wrong that is a bad sign.
The best advice is to develop skills in transcription. This will allow you to be a better musician.
Then again my advice is free.
The best advice is to develop skills in transcription. This will allow you to be a better musician.
Then again my advice is free.
I use tabs mostly as a starting point, because I'm too lazy to sit down and figure it all. At least, with most tabs (after weeding out the crappy ones), you get an idea how the song is played and I can figure out the rest, or at least come up with something that fits. I would never pretend a tab I write is 100 % correct. Most tabs advertised as "100 % accurate" are a bit like women who say they're not complicated: not entirely true !
OK, I am returning to bass playing after being away for 41 years. I have downloaded several tab versions of songs I used to play in the 1970's, that I had figured out by ear then, and still remember. ALL the tab versions I found for these songs were wrong: wrong notes, wrong fingering, wrong key. There is a LOT of bad stuff out there, but I keep hoping to find tab that is at least approximate: I have a lot of catching up to do, and any help is welcome!
especially when the guitarist still call the chords an E when in reality it is now F# for example ...
tab are always not so great, I've seen some transcription book like some RHCP official transcription with TAB and it happens here and there that the TAB is wrong or they choose some frets that make the line harder than it is or they TAB a Chorus in a way then on he second chorus they TAB it somewhere else on the neck ...
Better to learn how to read standart notation
Better to learn how to read standart notation
Yep, i used to look up songs i actusally knew how to play just to see how wrong the online tabs for it were. And they always were wrong, one way or another.
But if you ever see anything i tabbed, i guarantee you it's likely 98% accurate at least.
IF it wasn't. i wouldn't bother tabbing it.
Oh and about tab books being pretty accurate...not all of them. When i started i bought a Hal Leonard U2 bass tabs book (yeah i know, easy stuff that can easily be picked up by ear but was starting and didn't know any better). In particular i remember the bass tab for A Sort of Homecoming. I look in the book and i was like "whoa, this is ten times more complex than it sounds like!" Then i listened to the song again and could't figure out what they were hearing in the tabs. I let it be. When i got better about a year later i came back to it. The tab was full of ****. Whoever tabbed it decided to add like loads of notes that just aren't there. The original bass part is extremely simple. So it's pretty stupid. I believe there were a few more such examples in the tab book. It's like look, write what's there, if it's simple, great, easy money, but don't tab your crazy jams.
But if you ever see anything i tabbed, i guarantee you it's likely 98% accurate at least.
IF it wasn't. i wouldn't bother tabbing it.Oh and about tab books being pretty accurate...not all of them. When i started i bought a Hal Leonard U2 bass tabs book (yeah i know, easy stuff that can easily be picked up by ear but was starting and didn't know any better). In particular i remember the bass tab for A Sort of Homecoming. I look in the book and i was like "whoa, this is ten times more complex than it sounds like!" Then i listened to the song again and could't figure out what they were hearing in the tabs. I let it be. When i got better about a year later i came back to it. The tab was full of ****. Whoever tabbed it decided to add like loads of notes that just aren't there. The original bass part is extremely simple. So it's pretty stupid. I believe there were a few more such examples in the tab book. It's like look, write what's there, if it's simple, great, easy money, but don't tab your crazy jams.
TAB was a great resource until I developed my ear enough to play without it.
It's always been much easier to tell when I was playing the song wrong than when I was playing it right. Often people who aren't even musicians can tell when you're off key or off time.
It's always been much easier to tell when I was playing the song wrong than when I was playing it right. Often people who aren't even musicians can tell when you're off key or off time.
Tab is almost a complete waste of time. Learn to use your ears. Taking shortcuts isn't helping you, at all. Listening over and over and trying again and again are what gets you there.
I totally agree about tab but also don't trust Sheet. Most transcribers don't play bass and many don't play guitar.
If you don't believe me try the sheet for most of the Eagles songs. The only correct things are the key and the sing title (usually). Both of those are often right on tab too but i usually have those figured out after listening to a few bars.
If you don't believe me try the sheet for most of the Eagles songs. The only correct things are the key and the sing title (usually). Both of those are often right on tab too but i usually have those figured out after listening to a few bars.
