Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Would you take this gig?
- Thread starter baddarryl
- Start date
I agree with everyone who has said DO IT.
You will gain so much experience etc. etc.
HOWEVER....
That's when you gig a club or other scene, no pressure, you know what you're getting into.
I cannot see a winner in this as (not just this but virtually every situation in life) everyone is your friend and very supportive until something goes wrong.
When you've stumbled a few times or just sat out a song guess who the scape goat will be. More importantly when the gang huddle round the water cooler on Monday and discuss how you screwed the band at THEIR social, your wife has to face the sniggers etc. etc.
DO NOT DO IT
You will gain so much experience etc. etc.
HOWEVER....
That's when you gig a club or other scene, no pressure, you know what you're getting into.
I cannot see a winner in this as (not just this but virtually every situation in life) everyone is your friend and very supportive until something goes wrong.
When you've stumbled a few times or just sat out a song guess who the scape goat will be. More importantly when the gang huddle round the water cooler on Monday and discuss how you screwed the band at THEIR social, your wife has to face the sniggers etc. etc.
DO NOT DO IT
I'm a really serious player, a quick study on picking up songs, good ear, lots of experience, etc. I personally would not take the "gig", but I'd be happy to sit in and jam. Every time I'm in a situation where I hear a band jamming I think, oh, I could play that great, know it great, no issues. then I sit in and they choose song after song I have never heard at all, and guessing how a song goes is just not possible LoL.
You can make great music in jam mode - but it's not playing songs that people know, and it's not playing anything that a singer can sing over unless they are just improvisers also or songwriters.
Is this a songwriting jam challenge? I doubt it LoL, so I woudl say - hey, I'll sit in, have fun, but we won't be playing actual songs and I likely won't play much. Lower the expectations, then if you get the songs well, rock out and impress them.
You can make great music in jam mode - but it's not playing songs that people know, and it's not playing anything that a singer can sing over unless they are just improvisers also or songwriters.
Is this a songwriting jam challenge? I doubt it LoL, so I woudl say - hey, I'll sit in, have fun, but we won't be playing actual songs and I likely won't play much. Lower the expectations, then if you get the songs well, rock out and impress them.
I'd argue the other way - if they're paying the band, they're expecting professionalism, which isn't happening here. I wouldn't do a loosey goosey thing like this IF they were paying me.
No way in hell would I take a gig with no drummer, no setlist, and no prior experience with the other musicians. But if that kind of thing doesn't bother you, I guess go for it!
Do it! Any experience is good experience..
Just like you, I'm mediocre at best right now..
A couple of years back, got a call from a guitarist I had played with just a few times saying their bassist walked out and would I play.. HECK YEAH!
After that call, the head of the band called to confirm, and said he'd send the set list to start learning... he texted me 30 songs and also said, .. "by the way, we have a show Friday"... It was Wednesday ...
Yep, flubbed few times, but still got paid, AND .. got to do more gigs with them..
Point is.. take the gig
Write some originals as backup in the event that songs like “Take This Job and Shove It” are on the set list.
More importantly, get the crowd liquored up.
The more they drink, they better you'll sound.
At a younger age I would do it just for the educational value/sport of it. Now I would do it, provided the expectation was I needed the key. Please note if the were in a genre I new nothing about, it would be a hard pass.
I like how the OP has said he got it and thanked everybody yet, it has carried on 5 pages passed that!
We just love to see our own comments
He hears his own voice!
- Jul 7, 2010
- 3,383
- 2,311
- Disclosures
- Endorsing Artist for: Duncan Pickups; Line6, Hipshot, GHS Strings, Somnium Guitars
Personally NO...
Unless you were in the hills and just made up your own type of instruments and everyone were cousins, then maybe.
lol
Unless you were in the hills and just made up your own type of instruments and everyone were cousins, then maybe.
lol
I don't do train wrecks, and this sounds like it has all the earmarks of a train wreck waiting to happen. If I were you I would politely decline.
Admittedly I didn't read past the first few posts. Because it only started yesterday, and I figured he was probably still thinking about it. I think I'm going to stop commenting here at all because you just can't win unless you're willing to spend your entire day here.I like how the OP has said he got it and thanked everybody yet, it has carried on 5 pages passed that!
We just love to see our own comments
He hears his own voice!
