True words. Had a disproportionate situation earlier this year in a "who owns/pays for the PA" situation. In the end we ditched the band leader!
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
True words. Had a disproportionate situation earlier this year in a "who owns/pays for the PA" situation. In the end we ditched the band leader!
Sounds to me like the singer has left the band.
That being the case, if he wants a demo to take along when he moves, to help him get a new band together or find gigs or whatever, he can pay for the studio time himself and hire you at whatever the going rate is for studio bassists.
If you are friends, and you want to help him out, you could record for free. But you should not be paying for the studio time.
That being the case, if he wants a demo to take along when he moves, to help him get a new band together or find gigs or whatever, he can pay for the studio time himself and hire you at whatever the going rate is for studio bassists.
If you are friends, and you want to help him out, you could record for free. But you should not be paying for the studio time.
Big Hoss
Up note, down note, blue note, brown note...
- Sep 5, 2014
- 5,455
- 4,234
- Disclosures
- None
It sounds to me like your lead singer is trying to use you guys has the backing track for his own personal karaoke. Run don't just walk away from this deal.
7 weeks of prep for 4 songs??? That alone would have me walking.
Smooth_bass88
vaxx!
- Oct 31, 2006
- 12,122
- 16,794
- Disclosures
- have been on nationally released albums, charting on the Billboard 200
OMG, absolutely no way. You should be getting the $1700 for the session!!
My initial response would be "Not a chance!". But if you instead want to think through it logically without simply tell him to F off:
I would ask if the remaining band members agree that it's worth $1700 each to have that demo of your most recent 18 months for your own promotional purposes, your own enjoyment, or a combination of those or other factors. If so, then put up the money and go for it.
If not, then it sounds like you and the remaining band members won't get anything worthwhile from the project besides funding the singer's new career without you. Do you and the remaining band members agree that it's worth $1700 each to do that? If so, then go for it.
If not, then ask the remaining band members if you all agree that you'll rehearse and record for free without paying for the cost of the project. If so, then tell the singer you're willing to do that and he'll either agree or not.
If not, then those who do agree can make the offer to the singer and the rest would say goodbye. If the singer agrees then he would be on his own to find other musicians to hire to rehearse and record.
If not, then it sounds like your only remaining choice is, "Nice knowing you and good luck out there.".
I would ask if the remaining band members agree that it's worth $1700 each to have that demo of your most recent 18 months for your own promotional purposes, your own enjoyment, or a combination of those or other factors. If so, then put up the money and go for it.
If not, then it sounds like you and the remaining band members won't get anything worthwhile from the project besides funding the singer's new career without you. Do you and the remaining band members agree that it's worth $1700 each to do that? If so, then go for it.
If not, then ask the remaining band members if you all agree that you'll rehearse and record for free without paying for the cost of the project. If so, then tell the singer you're willing to do that and he'll either agree or not.
If not, then those who do agree can make the offer to the singer and the rest would say goodbye. If the singer agrees then he would be on his own to find other musicians to hire to rehearse and record.
If not, then it sounds like your only remaining choice is, "Nice knowing you and good luck out there.".
The problem I have with the situations where the band evenly splits the recording is this - what happens if one of the songs is discovered by someone and they want it on their movie soundtrack? Does everyone in the band get an even split and even sing writing credits or will the guitar player say that he wrote the song and he gets all money? Courts usually don't care about the bass line, just the lyrics, melody and chord progression.
Record your parts at home and send them to the producer. Otherwise, time for them to find a new bass player.
This!
All you need is a couple of mics, an interface and Reaper if you want those songs recorded.
Where is this singer moving to? If it's to Melbourne then he just wants a demo for a new band. There are so many more his in and around there than Sydney that a part of me would almost move from the country to live there.
If you have a six figure bank account then sure, otherwise, there are probably better charities.
Making money isn't a deal breaker here, however, the fact of no gigs or advancement is.
One song we've played for over 12 months and the others have been written as a band in the last 8 months. Great songs love playing them but I don't know if that's enough to justify the time and cost of recording.
Run--- I love all these folks who pay insane money to record "demo" tapes, etc... either record them for pennies yourself, or forget it. Because pennies are what they are worth. (other than as a personal memento).
