Yes and yes. Or is that +2?
For me, the woofer is the key to the tone. Run the P full and then dial in the woofer however you want. Running a 2-channel rig, while certainly a luxury, is the ideal way to make the low end be as enormous as you want while still maintaining the clarity of the P.
I can't believe I just referred to a P pickup as being clear.
I can confirm this after today's band rehearsal. I've always run my attitude blended out of one output. I occasionally run into 'mud' problems due to both pickups being full range. Besides, I've never been completely happy with either single band or dual band compression.
So I had a think to work out a way to make the most of the two outputs with the gear I've got. I ended up running the P pickup in my Pandora, set with a fairly heavy compression and a tubey amp sim with the low end dialed out, and the woofer into my White Finger compressor then into the Pandora's aux input. Thus mixing both signals out from the Pandora into my amp.
Oh my God! The sound was incredible. Fantastic note definition, clarity, grind and harmonics from the heavily compressed P - tapping was a breeze. But I still retained a fat, punchy, floor shaking low end, that didn't sound too compressed when I played way down low. Truly the best of both worlds. And the icing on the cake was no mud. Taking out the low end from the P gave the woofer room to breath and do it's job. They stopped fighting each other.
I also found I had a lot more control over tone using just the volume knobs. I had quite a gritty tone coming out the P in conjunction with the Pandora, but backing off the P's volume reigned in the grit and allowed me to get a more 'conventional' bass tone. No tone control required.
But the best thing is I know it can sound even better. The Pandora isn't really made for getting a high quality live tone, but I have a plan in mind that'll do exactly what I want, it just required a few beer token! I'm thinking a TC Nova Drive, TC Nova Dynamics and a Boss EQ pedal. I'd run the woofer into one side of the Nova Dynamics, and the P into the EQ to dial out some low end, into the Nova Drive for dirt when required then into the other side of the Nova Dynamics, then mix both out into the amp. The only thing I'll need to turn on and off is the drive, so I can run a G-Switch out to the front and keep the pedals at the back out of sight. (PS, pretty much settled on the Nova Drive due to it's 2 parrallel drive tones and the OD is blendable).