TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Could not resist me some Steven Wilson:
Oh heck yeah! Love that album and Hand Cannot Erase. Would love to see Luminol covered live.I don't blame you. We cover 'Luminol' in one band, and it's a lot of fun to play.
Agree. Jazz is hard to define. And it has some rhythmic and harmonic conventions. Some like swung triplets on a ride strongly suggest jazz- almost like a musical stereotype or quip. Which I think is what the former quote is about.
Specific genres of jazz have more definable elements. Dixieland, big band, swing, bop, cool, fusion, etc.
But I definitely think Improvisation- especially for solos is a key element. And jazz uses harmonic conventions more than major/minor. Not saying it's prescriptive (like has to use 7ths or 9ths or 11th), jazz just is likely to have "extended" harmonic elements.
Melodic conventions are cribbed from every where for jazz- so not sure you can assign a melodic element- it has melodies- but that might be it.
But jazz has also influenced so many other types of music since it came into it's own, it can be hard to parse out.
Swing is a great feel often used in jazz but I wouldn't say that it inputs "jazz" into a particular piece.
I see someone else already mentioned Naked City, but my friend, the band you seek is Imperial Triumphant. Actually, this is the exact opposite of what you asked for - it's metal with very heavy and obvious jazz, bebop, and big band influences, rather than "heavy" jazz. But it's still neat.