• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Angine de Poitrine (Live on KEXP)

It's kind of a perfect storm: Rick Beato is an old muso who's got a huge youtube following, and AdP are (comparatively) brand-new band with a suddenly huge youtube following.

I've been struck by the number of old guys (like me) who really dug that KEXP video. I'm a little surprised Beato gave his thumbs up but that's going to legitimize AdP to the kind of older musician and music lover who might usually only watch his videos about how terrible the music is that kids listen to these days.
Agree. I'm just a little dissapointed that he obviously made the whole video only in order to clear his mailbox.

He could have done a much deeper analysis of their style: highlight unusual time signature, or he could have played a riff with a normal guitar to show how different it would sound... There are so many things he could have said.

Let's spam his mailbox again to ask him for a deeper analysis :smug:
 
I've been struck by the number of old guys (like me) who really dug that KEXP video. I'm a little surprised Beato gave his thumbs up but that's going to legitimize AdP to the kind of older musician and music lover who might usually only watch his videos about how terrible the music is that kids listen to these days.
Maybe because it's mainly (some of) us old guys who have been listening to stuff like Zappa, Mahavishnu Orchestra, King Crimson all our lives. I don't know who younger folks have been listening to in recent years that would prepare them for this.
 
Agree. I'm just a little dissapointed that he obviously made the whole video only in order to clear his mailbox.

He could have done a much deeper analysis of their style: highlight unusual time signature, or he could have played a riff with a normal guitar to show how different it would sound... There are so many things he could have said.

Let's spam his mailbox again to ask him for a deeper analysis :smug:
This was the first time I've watched one of his videos, so I don't what his sense of humor is like, but I thought the please-stop-emailing-me thing was meant in jest. He clearly dug the music when playing clips and seemed impressed by it.

That said, I too would like to see him do an in-depth analysis, and I suspect he probably is already getting spammed with such requests.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Daniel B5
I'm in no hurry to find out if this is ultimately profound to me or just a curiosity.
To my mind, the word "profound" sets an extremely high bar. Maybe time will tell whether this outfit clears that bar, but here's a (tentative) argument for using that word now:

This band is "weird" in multiple ways, but in ways that have all been done before: e.g. "math-rock" composition; odd time signatures; microtonal melody and harmony; multi-level looping; funny costumes. (Did I miss anything?) But these guys are doing all of those things at the same time and -- and I think this is maybe the "profound" part -- doing it in a way that you can dance to it.
 
I'll check them out. I really prefer live concert videos: Can you recommend one or two on YouTube?
Horse Lords don't have a lot in common with AdP other than not observing conventional 12TET systems. Horse Lords is more like motorik extrapolated to encompass minimalism and electronica. Or something like that. They're really good though.

AdP appears to use quarter tone (24TET) scales, Horse Lords uses Just Intonation, so they don't sound much alike.

A couple of my favorites. The first one was recorded in 2020 during Covid lockdown, when the Tusk Festival (just like every other music fest and everything else) was fully remote.

 
OK, now this is the kind of analysis I was expecting:


Agreed. There are plenty of "reaction videos" in which posers watch something they (allegedly) haven't seen before and respond in real time, and these can be fun in some ways, but this guy knows music and did his homework first. I especially liked his discussion of time signatures and the "math-rock" aspect of this, including the ways in which the band "pivots" from one time signature to another.

The only part I'm not sure about: I get the "Dada" idea, but if (as he says) the purpose is to help me ignore the visuals it definitely isn't working.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gtirard and WG Plum
If you like these guys, you might also like Horse Lords. I certainly do.

I did indeed like this, though I have to agree with @ardgedee that they're not really in the same category as AdP. I plan to check out the two vids @ardgedee posted tonight.
 
It's kind of a perfect storm: Rick Beato is an old muso who's got a huge youtube following, and AdP are (comparatively) brand-new band with a suddenly huge youtube following.

I've been struck by the number of old guys (like me) who really dug that KEXP video. I'm a little surprised Beato gave his thumbs up but that's going to legitimize AdP to the kind of older musician and music lover who might usually only watch his videos about how terrible the music is that kids listen to these days.
I don't want to live in a world where "Rick Beato likes it" means anything!

;)

But seriously, I kid Rick Beato. But I didn't know he did a vid yesterday. I read a GP article on them and went looking for them and found that KEXP concert, and fell in love. It reminded me of the first time I heard Devo on Dr. Demento. If I wasn't Medicare adjacent, I'd consider it as life changing as Devo.