• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Another CL gem

I get into arguments with vinyl purists who insist vinyl is a more pure & accurate sound than digital. (well, i limit how often, when, and with who, but still)

Without going through my entire argument, vinyl's not more pure nor more accurate. The things they like about the sound of vinyl are the flaws and inaccuracies. I'm not saying it's wrong for them to like vinyl better. It's just not this pure & perfectly accurate thing that people think it is. And then good luck keeping whatever fidelity the records have after repeated plays. They've done tests where people can discern quality degradation after only 30 plays when compared to a brand new record.

I'm right there with you thinking this "revival" is a step backwards.

That said, the "revival" is only 6% of all music revenue. Nowhere near the 70% of revenue that vinyl used to be at one point. CDs are somewhere around 3% these days. Every once in a while i buy a CD for my aunt or parents because they don't do streaming or digital downloads. Every few years i even see some people try (and fail) to make a cassette tape revival too. WHY??? :rollno: So vinyl and CDs are still around, but barely.

If you like CDs, keep rockin'em! Just don't tell AL-X. He might try to get you to join his 12 song Black Sabbath band so you can play bass just like on the CDs, and you'll spend one practice per month going over the same songs with just AL-X and no drums or vocals. :nailbiting: :dead: :laugh:
I don’t know many people who can still play CDs anywhere other than their car. Similar thing to what happened to tapes 20 years ago.

But I know lots of people who take pride in their vinyl collection. Even if the way they generally listen to music is off spotify over bluetooth.
 
I don't see a problem. Maybe the rest of the band "has it down." Maybe... Just because GEEZER can do what He wants... well... He's GEEZER. Maybe... the crowd has heard the ALBUM 10,000 TIMES. Maybe... the guitar player wants to DO IT RIGHT. Maybe... he/she has some gigs lined up, to where THIS MATTERS, and he/she ARE A PROFESSSIONAL. They aren't difficult lines to master. They are fun/easy/AWESOME. Do a little bit of work.

Thread over.
You should apply! You fit the position!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MattZilla
Here are the stream of responses I received, all without further solicitation by me:
View attachment 5469076

View attachment 5469077

I just responded moments ago questioning his state of perfection when he failed to spell "rehearsal" correctly. I wonder if I should explain how I was too busy learning Zeppelin and Steely Dan. . . Nah, I'm an AH, but I think I'm done.
What a wonderful guy! I bet he's real fun to hang out with...
 
This^
A tribute band is always going to be a different animal from a bunch of Joes knocking out covers of their favorite songs in the vain hope that there will be an audience wanting to hear them down at the Drunken Clam. A tribute band is somewhat like a musical or play, follow the script and hit your mark. Sure, this guy may be A-personality, but he wants to get it done.
This situation wouldn’t be my idea of a good time, but if he can bring it, I see no problem.
I hear he'll be looking for a drummer soon! You may qualify!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoCal80s
We have a guy round here who trolls on Craigslist for band mates. It’s a revolving door as players come and go. 12-15 original songs that need to be played like their recording. All new songs to be written (including bass parts) by the singer songwriter. Pay is low but creating art is its own reward!
 
This^
A tribute band is always going to be a different animal from a bunch of Joes knocking out covers of their favorite songs in the vain hope that there will be an audience wanting to hear them down at the Drunken Clam. A tribute band is somewhat like a musical or play, follow the script and hit your mark. Sure, this guy may be A-personality, but he wants to get it done.
This situation wouldn’t be my idea of a good time, but if he can bring it, I see no problem.

Pretty sure Pete and Roger didn't demand that Pino work with Pete until the bass sounded exactly like Entwistle's original recordings.

Just pointing this out because trying to mimic recordings can be far less authentic than other choices.