• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bass Distortion pedals you'd recommend?

My main bass dirt is an old Source Audio Multiwave Bass Distortion. I use it for basic distortion and octave fuzz. Super easy to dial in and it rips. Prior to the Multiwave, I used a DOD Carcosa. It has great range and I prefer it to op-amp/hard clip distortions like RAT and DOD 250 based pedals. I've never had success with Big Muff based pedals.
I have a Carcosa my dirt path now is Scorpion > SubSpace > Carcosa.

I'm moving the Scorpion to another smaller board to pair with the Calamity.

So rather soon dirt path will be DCX BASS> SubSpace or MBD3 > Carcosa or Red muck bass.

But I'm completely open to ideas for the SubSpace spot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maxi Funkl
Let me start by saying I'm just starting to accept I dig dirt pedals. I have come to a decent understanding of Overdrive & Fuzz pedals. But distortion is not so clear. Rat vs Tube Screamer vs Mosfett vs Silicone vs etc and so on.

My dirt pedal exposure isn't vast. But I've gone through a few MojoMojo too dark. Rodenberg LDB Deluxe kind of cool but too big. Hamstead Subspace Killer pedal so many options but mine is noisy as heck. Scorpion killer not going anywhere but it's more Overdrive/EQ pedal.

So, I'm looking to replace the Subspace or at least discover potential options. 1st thought was MDB 3 like the Subspace tons of options. Do wish it was smaller. Maybe Rattler Bass? What's your favorite type of distortion and pedals. I'd prefer top jacks but I won't rule side Jack's out. Board ergonomics does matter.
If you can find one, check out a Broughton Audio Locust Star. I recommend it because it's a great sounding RAT, it's very versatile, and they come up for secondhand much more often than his other dirt pedals. I have one and it's not come off my boards for several years. I could almost justify getting a second one...
 
What about the [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]?
Had one for a while. It's not bad, not by any means, but I personally couldn't get along with the 100Hz bass frequency. 80Hz is more my thing, and considering that I play with distortion on like 90% of the time, I really didn't need the option to have a clean channel. Same reason I went with the X7 in stead of the XUltra
 
For real "distortion" (like guitar) that's not just dirt /fuzz, the EBS Sheehan Ultimate is it. From your post it sounds like this is what you want. Aggressive OD that's very smooth, and lots of control to hone the character and tone, and also balance it with a clean signal. I have alot of fun with this pedal. The clean signal channel means you don't have to lose low end or round-wound type bass tone. Built-in 2-level compressor which can also be switched off.
 
Let me start by saying I'm just starting to accept I dig dirt pedals. I have come to a decent understanding of Overdrive & Fuzz pedals. But distortion is not so clear. Rat vs Tube Screamer vs Mosfett vs Silicone vs etc and so on.

My dirt pedal exposure isn't vast. But I've gone through a few MojoMojo too dark. Rodenberg LDB Deluxe kind of cool but too big. Hamstead Subspace Killer pedal so many options but mine is noisy as heck. Scorpion killer not going anywhere but it's more Overdrive/EQ pedal.

So, I'm looking to replace the Subspace or at least discover potential options. 1st thought was MDB 3 like the Subspace tons of options. Do wish it was smaller. Maybe Rattler Bass? What's your favorite type of distortion and pedals. I'd prefer top jacks but I won't rule side Jack's out. Board ergonomics does matter.
There are a million out there and it is hard to keep track of them. Personally, I find that too many of the consumer level ones you can find in a store are just guitar pedals with a different name on them. If they have a blend, it's a lousy blend (I'm talking to you Boss ODB-3!!)
Personally, insist that a bass drive pedal have a good blend, or that I use it with a blend pedal. There is too much tone suck on most drive pedals that will ruin your articulation and low end.
Some circuits like the Rat can actually increase your articulation if you use the right settings. Some, like a tube screamer circuit will compress your articulation. 90% of fuzz pedals will smash your articulation, which might be what you are after.
Darkglass has done a lot of great work on making usable bass drive pedals, but they do have a very modern sound; articulate but very scooped. I have a B7k Ultra that I use as a preamp with moderate gain settings.

It's a deep, dark rabbit whole that is easy to disappear down. The upside is that the market for used pedals makes it easy to buy and sell them while you look for the one you want.
 
It would very much help if you gave a tone you were aiming for. The world of bass distortion is quite large these days! Here would be my suggestions:

MBD Family - Excellent, versatile pedals, all of them. I have tried the 1 and 2, and prefer the 2. The 3 was recently released, and is getting rave reviews. The short version of the descriptions between 2 & 3 are that the 2 is apparently more "full range" in tone, which I like. The 3 has a built in boost, though, so you can potentially get 2 tones out of 1 pedal. I use MBD2s for a modern metal sort of tone, but they can do lighter gain just as well. Simply amazing pedals. I find them to be great for smooth and articulate grit, if that makes sense. It's not chunky like a fuzz, but there's definitely some grit in the mix.

Rats - I have recently (in the past year or so) come to love and embrace Rats. They are definitely grittier than the MBD family overall. It's sort of a halfway point between fuzz and overdrive. But you have to find the right one. My favorites (in order) are the Dunwich/Magic Pedals Volt Thrower, Blue Colander Tremond, Frost Giant Bass Mountain, and Earthbound Audio Iron Pig (which I believe is discontinued). The biggest thing with each of these is that it will take time to find your tone. They are each a tweaker's delight, and can do all sorts of tones from mild to wild. They may also require re-tooling settings when you change rigs. I just did a small Rat shootout between the Volt Thrower and Tremond a few minutes ago, and while the Volt Thrower remained my #1, I could get almost identical tones from the Tremond, and get tones from the Tremond I couldn't get from the Volt Thrower. So the right one may also depend on the exact tone you're wanting, and the rig you have. They sounded nearly identical on my 700RB-II, but then I had to re-tool the Tremond when I put it on rig #2 - a 400RB-IV. It was much more brittle sounding on the 400RB-IV, but that was soon remedied. I also had a Cat Tail from Fuzzrocious, which gets great reviews here on TB. Didn't work for me, but nothing wrong with that option either, and they will be happy to add mods to it if you want them. If you're not sure about Rats and want something a little easier to obtain, the MXR Bass Distortion is also Rat-based, and was designed by Ryan from Fuzzrocious. It also gets great reviews here, but I've never played one.

Pork Loin - I LOVE this pedal, but would caution against using it as a distortion. It's low gain, and mostly an overdrive, and only gets to low gain distortion in the last third of its gain range. It can also be dark un-modded. It's a simple mod, and even an amateur can do it (I'm proof of that!), but the mod brightens it up a bit. This is likely my most usable pedal, as it just works in anything, but again, I'd be wary of expecting a "distortion" pedal from it.

HM-2 - Again, not sure what sort of distortion you're wanting... but if you want something incredibly heavy, this could be the ticket. It's a nice tone for sure, and I have plenty of experience with it, but most people don't want this distortion. Just in case, though, I thought I'd mention it. There are tons of takes on this pedal now, with my favorites being the Dunwich DIY HM-2, Bear Amps Heavier Metal, Earthbound Audio Throat Locust, and the original. But there are plenty of clones to choose from.

I could go on with more details on plenty of other pedals as well, but don't really know what you may be interested in. I also quite like the B3K (never had luck with the bigger versions) and the old Ibanez PD7. There are also plenty of fuzzes that can do distortion as well as fuzz, with the Russian Muffs fairly well known for this. I'd argue my Pharaoh Supreme and Swollen Pickle settings straddle the line between fuzz and distortion.

I'd be happy to go into more detail if you have any specific questions.
 
It would very much help if you gave a tone you were aiming for. The world of bass distortion is quite large these days! Here would be my suggestions:

MBD Family - Excellent, versatile pedals, all of them. I have tried the 1 and 2, and prefer the 2. The 3 was recently released, and is getting rave reviews. The short version of the descriptions between 2 & 3 are that the 2 is apparently more "full range" in tone, which I like. The 3 has a built in boost, though, so you can potentially get 2 tones out of 1 pedal. I use MBD2s for a modern metal sort of tone, but they can do lighter gain just as well. Simply amazing pedals. I find them to be great for smooth and articulate grit, if that makes sense. It's not chunky like a fuzz, but there's definitely some grit in the mix.

Rats - I have recently (in the past year or so) come to love and embrace Rats. They are definitely grittier than the MBD family overall. It's sort of a halfway point between fuzz and overdrive. But you have to find the right one. My favorites (in order) are the Dunwich/Magic Pedals Volt Thrower, Blue Colander Tremond, Frost Giant Bass Mountain, and Earthbound Audio Iron Pig (which I believe is discontinued). The biggest thing with each of these is that it will take time to find your tone. They are each a tweaker's delight, and can do all sorts of tones from mild to wild. They may also require re-tooling settings when you change rigs. I just did a small Rat shootout between the Volt Thrower and Tremond a few minutes ago, and while the Volt Thrower remained my #1, I could get almost identical tones from the Tremond, and get tones from the Tremond I couldn't get from the Volt Thrower. So the right one may also depend on the exact tone you're wanting, and the rig you have. They sounded nearly identical on my 700RB-II, but then I had to re-tool the Tremond when I put it on rig #2 - a 400RB-IV. It was much more brittle sounding on the 400RB-IV, but that was soon remedied. I also had a Cat Tail from Fuzzrocious, which gets great reviews here on TB. Didn't work for me, but nothing wrong with that option either, and they will be happy to add mods to it if you want them. If you're not sure about Rats and want something a little easier to obtain, the MXR Bass Distortion is also Rat-based, and was designed by Ryan from Fuzzrocious. It also gets great reviews here, but I've never played one.

Pork Loin - I LOVE this pedal, but would caution against using it as a distortion. It's low gain, and mostly an overdrive, and only gets to low gain distortion in the last third of its gain range. It can also be dark un-modded. It's a simple mod, and even an amateur can do it (I'm proof of that!), but the mod brightens it up a bit. This is likely my most usable pedal, as it just works in anything, but again, I'd be wary of expecting a "distortion" pedal from it.

HM-2 - Again, not sure what sort of distortion you're wanting... but if you want something incredibly heavy, this could be the ticket. It's a nice tone for sure, and I have plenty of experience with it, but most people don't want this distortion. Just in case, though, I thought I'd mention it. There are tons of takes on this pedal now, with my favorites being the Dunwich DIY HM-2, Bear Amps Heavier Metal, Earthbound Audio Throat Locust, and the original. But there are plenty of clones to choose from.

I could go on with more details on plenty of other pedals as well, but don't really know what you may be interested in. I also quite like the B3K (never had luck with the bigger versions) and the old Ibanez PD7. There are also plenty of fuzzes that can do distortion as well as fuzz, with the Russian Muffs fairly well known for this. I'd argue my Pharaoh Supreme and Swollen Pickle settings straddle the line between fuzz and distortion.

I'd be happy to go into more detail if you have any specific questions.
Great insight thank you!
This statement right here would be exactly what I'm looking for ( It's sort of a halfway point between fuzz and overdrive.) Also, since I have very little exposure up to now to dirt pedals in theory I know what I want but completely learning as I go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kleinenenten
Tops for me are, as already mentioned,

The MBD (1 or 2, haven't bought the 3 yet.

Broughton Scorpion (FMV tonestack located post gain, with a pre gain bass control labeled depth)

Fuzzrocious Lil Fella. Interactive gain/drive controls, with an excellent sweep on the tone control.

Honorable mention to a few,

Darkglass B3K.
Poison Noises The Crook.
DOD FX91 Bass Overdrive.
 
Great insight thank you!
This statement right here would be exactly what I'm looking for ( It's sort of a halfway point between fuzz and overdrive.) Also, since I have very little exposure up to now to dirt pedals in theory I know what I want but completely learning as I go.
Then my suggestion would be a Rat of some sort. Way back when, I bought the Iron Pig to be my "fuzz" on a second board instead of using another Muff. It never quite got the tones I was looking for then, but right now, I have Muff tone and a Rat tone that are somewhat similar. The biggest difference is that the Rat is more high-mid and treble-focused with bite to it and the Muff is more low and low-mid focused with some thump, and a little smoother tone overall. But besides the EQ, they sound and react very similarly in my current settings. You can also get a Rat to be a bit "clanky", if that's your thing. My favorite Rats for that "halfway between fuzz and overdrive" would probably be the Tremond, which is my #2 overall. The Volt Thrower I currently use for a little "clankier" tone, and it does quite well for that. The Tremond is also set very similarly at the moment, but can do the halfway point stuff a little easier I feel. The Bass Mountain is also incredibly good at that.

Not sure where you're located, but the Bass Mountain is readily available at online retailers in the US. The Cat Tail is also readily available in the US. The Iron Pig is discontinued I believe (or will be soon), and the Volt Thrower is only made sporadically and in small batches. The Tremond is made in Poland and may be easier to get if you're in Europe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maxi Funkl