Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Basses and genres
- Thread starter Yonni
- Start date
I voted no, but it's really yes and no.
Yes: any bass that's playable, stays in tune and has a usable signal can be used effectively in any genre.
No: I wouldn't take a fretless 6 or an upright to a rock gig, and i wouldn't show up to a jazz/standards gig with a precision. (But I could make any of those work if I had to.)
Yes: any bass that's playable, stays in tune and has a usable signal can be used effectively in any genre.
No: I wouldn't take a fretless 6 or an upright to a rock gig, and i wouldn't show up to a jazz/standards gig with a precision. (But I could make any of those work if I had to.)
IMO is it about how you play and not what you play. From 1995 to 2021 I played single H stingray and single H sterling for everything. Rock, country, swamp pop, jazz, church choir, punk and what ever else I played during that time. No one ever said my bass sounded bad or out of place. I really don't think people notice. My basses are neutral colors (black ray, grey sterling) so they really do not stand out visually.
EdwardofHuncote
I Still Dream of Jeannie
- Aug 21, 2013
- 6,644
- 2
- 16,407
- Disclosures
- I privately own and operate a local musical instument repair shop.
Alembic fretless 5-string, with an oldtyme string band. Last Saturday.
As long as I have one with flats, rounds, and fretless I can find what I need in the tone. I don’t buy into having a bass that looks like the guitars. I don’t object to it. But nothing wrong with some dude plucking a Ray while the guitarist is stomping around with an SG. Am I right?
Thank you for saving me the time, as soon as I read the comment about Thumbs & Corvettes I started thinking about all the videos I could post depicting the contrary
Scott of Scott's Bass Lessons claims his favorite bass for jazz is a P.
Not sure about that one, sounds like a reach. Maybe if the guitarist was in a school boy outfit it might work. Who knows.
Strings, strings, strings! Gimme any bass with the option to use the strings of my choice and I'll take a crack at it.
Everybody had their own definition of "jazz." Suffice it to say Scott's definition may be at odds with mine.
I vote like most did anything sounds right if you are good enough
although I think it is more about design than sound
may stand out a little if you bring this to a church gig
although I think it is more about design than sound
may stand out a little if you bring this to a church gig
Last edited:
Yes and no. Any bass can work for any style, but some period specific styles are defined by the bass used.
The obvious one... I would never use a stingray in a Motown cover band. Like wise, if I'm playing a bunch of 90s music I'm immediately going for the Ray.
The obvious one... I would never use a stingray in a Motown cover band. Like wise, if I'm playing a bunch of 90s music I'm immediately going for the Ray.
I guess that’s a joke. It’s Cordell “Boogie” Mosson
Real Jazz is from Utah!Everybody had their own definition of "jazz." Suffice it to say Scott's definition may be at odds with mine.
I thought my old Warwick was the best bass for jazz ... and metal ... and country ... and musical theatre ... and indie/lounge ... and whatever else I was doing over the decade when that was my only bass guitar.
