• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bassists you just can't watch

Petty much any rock bassist who plays pickstyle strumming up high towards the neck(and I don't mean picking clearly up there--just sort of strumming--and not as an occasional effect, but as their main style). You just know they're making a horrendously messy undefined racket that the soundman/engineer is having to mush into the mix to get it to work.

Vinnie Hornsby from Sevendust. I've seen him record in the studio and he sits and uses a traditional picking style and position. Live he looks ********. Bass past his knees, picking (or whatever) right on the 20th fret of his Epiphone Les Paul bass. I don't know why, I just don't. Morgan Rose is one of the best drummers I've ever heard or seen, but what a bizarre rhythm section companion he's got. I cannot stand watching Vinnie play.
 
+3
For reals yo

its just downright lame to play bass with a pick i dont care what anyone says
if anyone tries to play my bass wit da pick i kick them in the balls

*metaphorically speaking of course...

I play fingerstyle myself. But . . . Chris Squire. That's about all I ever need to hear when someone wanks about playing bass with a pick. In fact, I think I'll put Fragile on going to work today just to hear it again.

What is it that you can't get? The tone? The technique? If you're of the mistaken view that Squire a pick-player lacks in either of those just put on a classic Yes CD and you will get some schooling.
 
If no one mentioned him earlier, Sting's technique is god-awful. That whole thumb-picking thing looks like a borrowed guitar usage; what's weird is that I have seen him use standard two-finger plucking technique (on this one song "Let Your Soul Be Your Pilot").

Also, his fretting technique looks very clumsy -- almost as if his hand is too small for a regular-scale bass.

He's just as awkard on the guitar, too.

Also, I've never been a fan of Jack Bruce's "clawhammer" picking technique (even though I think he's a brilliant player). And Paul McCartney looks like a guitarist playing bass, as well.
 
I can't stand Billy Sheehan. His sound is like mic'ing a fart and sending it through a tube amp...

I have to grudgingly agree here. Billy is from my hometown. he is a few years older than me and so I have seen him off and on for many years. An amazing player but I have never,ever dug his sound. Nowhere near my idea of what the instrument should sound like.

JKT:hmm: