• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Behringer XR18 X-Air

One of the bands I play with has the Keys play supplying PA and doing sound, so I don't get to use my XR18. The drummer and I both like to use IEM where ever possible, but the keys player's desk doesn't have enough aux sends. I'm toying with the idea of buying 2 8 channel splitter snakes so I can take all the instruments to my XR18, so that I can supply the drummer and I stereo IEM.

Has anyone done this and did they have any issues?
If the main desk is supplying phantom power to Condenser Mics etc, will the splitter snake interfere with that?
This is EXACTLY what we do.. only for the whole band.. Take a look at an older post of mine.. There's a 16-ch splitter snake (I don't recall the brand) hidden behind the rack in the pic.
One side goes to the IEM rack (and x32) and the other goes to the House
Has anyone gone full wireless (bass, mic, monitors) for live use?

As @Geri O stated - if all is wired correctly, phantom power should not be an issue!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rocksolid
Hi all, bein a long time analog mixer guy I am struggling with wrapping my head around some things in the digital world of the XR. I get things in theory but the execution in the heat of battle has been confounding, especially on the monitor side. The last 2-3 shows I have creatd a hell for myself and thd band and I am embarrassed but determined. I think at some point along the way I had squirreled something up in the input choices or FX and caused myself thsi grief. Today I re-initialized everything and am starting over now that I have settled on the iPad as the tablet of choice to mix from.

Quick first question as I reset things. On the channels hat you run the high pass/Low cut filter, what frequency are you setting it at? I engaged the HPF and it's defaulting to 20hz. But that's not really useful. Running KW181 subs passed at 80-100hz so I know that as long as I am 110hz or above that will keep me out of the subs but is that a good setting for a HPF in general?
 
I use a HPF of 100Hz on vocals and guitar, and something in that neighborhood for all drum mics except the kick.

100hz is a good default. I high-pass everything but kick drum and bass, sometimes no high-pass on the floor tom, if that kinda sound is desirable in the genre I'm working. Keys, snare, toms and guitars at 80 to 100, vocals 100, female vocals 125 or so, then various horns and percussion instruments vary. High hats around 400, overheads at 150 (if you want to have some drum ambience) or 3-400 if you want cymbals only.
 
Hi all, bein a long time analog mixer guy I am struggling with wrapping my head around some things in the digital world of the XR. I get things in theory but the execution in the heat of battle has been confounding, especially on the monitor side. The last 2-3 shows I have creatd a hell for myself and thd band and I am embarrassed but determined. I think at some point along the way I had squirreled something up in the input choices or FX and caused myself thsi grief. Today I re-initialized everything and am starting over now that I have settled on the iPad as the tablet of choice to mix from.

Quick first question as I reset things. On the channels hat you run the high pass/Low cut filter, what frequency are you setting it at? I engaged the HPF and it's defaulting to 20hz. But that's not really useful. Running KW181 subs passed at 80-100hz so I know that as long as I am 110hz or above that will keep me out of the subs but is that a good setting for a HPF in general?

You haven't provided much detail regarding the trouble you've had, but since you mention high pass and low pass, I would high-pass every channel except kick, bass, keys and break music around 100 or even higher. I also high pass the monitor busses up to 200, and have seen others go as high as 400! Make sure you have the mains on when you check to see how the monitors sound so the mains and subs fill in the bottom. Bring the low pass down on the monitors until you start to hear it on vocals. This is just a start. I might have more suggestions if you provide more details on what's gone wrong.

One more pearl of wisdom. If your band mates control their own monitor mixes and have wedges rather than IEMS, make them get it right at sound check and leave it alone. There is nothing worse than having someone mess with their mix in the middle of the set without telling you, introduce a bunch of feedback then expect you to fix it when you have music to play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nervous
You haven't provided much detail regarding the trouble you've had, but since you mention high pass and low pass, I would high-pass every channel except kick, bass, keys and break music around 100 or even higher. I also high pass the monitor busses up to 200, and have seen others go as high as 400! Make sure you have the mains on when you check to see how the monitors sound so the mains and subs fill in the bottom. Bring the low pass down on the monitors until you start to hear it on vocals. This is just a start. I might have more suggestions if you provide more details on what's gone wrong.

One more pearl of wisdom. If your band mates control their own monitor mixes and have wedges rather than IEMS, make them get it right at sound check and leave it alone. There is nothing worse than having someone mess with their mix in the middle of the set without telling you, introduce a bunch of feedback then expect you to fix it when you have music to play.

That's true, I guess I didn't want to muddy the HPF question wth other things. I did say 'high pass/Low cut filter' not anything low pass. My question was specifically aimed at ballpark, starting point HPF settings and there ae plenty here to work with. Thank you all.

To teh details, my main issues have really been with the monitor side of things. FWIW I use 2 to 6 QSC K12 for mains along with 2 to 4 KW181 subs, and everyone in the 4 piece band gets a K12 for a floor monitor. The drummer plays an electric kit and he gets an added kSub in a side fill drum stach about 4'-5' away to round things out. I had run things quite nicely with an A&H MixWiz 16 and a few rack EQs. In fact, the first time I used that setup with this new band they raved. They still reference that job. Best any of them had had, including the drummer. No issues, plenty of volume and clarity, minimal EQing needed. Shortly after that I got the bug to go digital, again, after seeing the XR18. Just a fabulous package for what I need. So I did. In between I left the prior project and moved full time to this new band so not a lot of live work to experiment with but now have four jobs of differing sizes to reference.

In this order there was one medium basic bar setup, one smaller basic bar setup, one large banquet hall style venue with a large high steel stage, hollow underneath, and boxy, gym/aerobics studio style room. Compounding things is that I have tried three different control platforms across the last three months. First the iPad. A) because I had it and B) because I was familiar. This was pre-recent update. It wasn't great then, and a friend decided to 'help us out' that first night and run from the front. Job 1 night told me I needed a dedicated control unit so that I didn't have to give up my playing notes and lyrics. The Android was the next trial because most folks found that to be really primitive and clunky. At that time, some ways better than the iPad and in many other ways not. But neither suited me yet. Then, because I really liked the X-Air PC interface I decided a Windows based 2-in-1 was going to solve my problems. Interestingly, about the time that PC #2 arrived there was teh major XAir update for all platforms and that made the iPad a whle new ballgame. But, after trying a couple different convertible models, and breaking it out at job 2, that was miserable. Not touch responsive and damn if things weren't tiny! just not for me. So for that second job I went back to the iPad to get through. Again, FOH was great, monitors just not wheer they had been. So I ditched and sold the windows machind and wehn back to deciding if teh Android or iPad was going to be it. At job three we had the luxury of seting up a couple days early and testing some things out. FRont side of things came together quickly, as had been teh pattern. But again, the monitors were just impossible. Odd feedback, high and low sneaking up out of seemingly no where. no clarity, everything seemed on teh edge of badness yet no one was happy with what they had. Frustration and panic was setting in and banging away on that Android interface was the last straw. We ended up turning the kSub down in the drum stack and that identified one issue it seems. We think the hollow staging compounded our issues but don't know. The entire show was a crappy compromise in getting through. After that I decided that the iPad woudl become my main control and teh Android woudl hold my noted and be available as a backup.

And, job 4 was the worst. FOH up and running with flying colors. Monitors were possessed. Drum stack was a battle that I lost to little useful coming through and the same low hornish feedback or high 4k style feedback. Standing in front of it with the iPad watching the RTA the EQ seemed to have no effect on anything. The main singers monitor was so hot and even when his Aux was muted the signal continued to come out. I was again baffled. And frustrated. The night was shot for everyone before it started. At this point is where I decided to simply reset everything ans start from scratch. Hoping that somewhere in my playing around and many devices that a setting or two got changed that I could not ID. I once had a similar circumstance with a Presonus 16.4.2 on an early job wheer there was monitor signal passing where there shouldn't have been any and I found some FX dialed in somewhere it didn't belong. Hoping that my incompetence with this unit caused the same issues.

Whatever issues I have I am 99.9% sure they are self inflicted. And because I can have stellar results with the same equipment on an analog board and endless misery with this digital system means I am clearly not understanding something very basic. Finding that is teh challengs before teh next job. But, as the weather improved here in teh northeast I'll be able to get to the garage and set some things up for live testing that Ive not been able to do the past few months. Thay will bring some peace of mind as well.
 
The main singers monitor was so hot and even when his Aux was muted the signal continued to come out.

That sounds like the singer's mic could be feeding an FX send that is routed to the monitor's aux.

If you haven't already checked the aux sends that feed your monitors, try pulling any FX out of those sends, and disabling the aux's overall comp and eq. If those are wet, they can make your monitors a hot mess.
 
I understand that this thread is dedicated to the XR mixers and certainly don't want to take anything away from them but I do want to put forward some experience for people who are still undecided on what platform to invest in.

I've been keeping up to date with this thread for quite some time and was all but sold on the XR series until I was able to have a play with the user interface on the Soundcraft Ui series. If you're like me (older and more at home with a standard basic analogue mixing desk) you'll find the Ui so much easier to work with. It really does work like a normal desk and getting set up and working was really easy, especially doing foldback setup and mixing, and the sound quality is excellent.

Now for the downsides. There are reports of (and i've experienced it once in 40 or 50 times using my Ui12) the connection freezing requiring a reboot of the system to regain control. Not a big issue if you've already got your mix sorted as it'll still pass signal but you can't tweak anything until you reboot. Not good if it's a really important gig and I can't recall reading of anything similar happening to the XR mixers.

Another thing is that the XR mixers have a LOT more options for routing channels Aux buses etc. The downside of that (and the reason I went with the Ui) is that you can really get lost if you don't have good knowledge of digital mixing.

Finally, from what i've seen Behringer has been a lot more proactive in helping their customers get the most out of their mixer. Soundcraft on the other hand have been very much missing in action for customers with problems.

Anyway, just thought I'd throw that in there for anyone looking at this thread that is in the market for a digital mixer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nervous
Agreed. Back to square 1 for your monitor sends, make sure everything's dry and flat, then go from there.

Are you familiar with the procedure for "ringing out" monitors? The built-in RTA overlaid on the GEQ is really helpful here.

In case you haven't already seen them, Behringer has a pretty decent series of YouTube videos that explain the basics of running the X Air mixers. I learned a thing or two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nervous
That sounds like the singer's mic could be feeding an FX send that is routed to the monitor's aux.

If you haven't already checked the aux sends that feed your monitors, try pulling any FX out of those sends, and disabling the aux's overall comp and eq. If those are wet, they can make your monitors a hot mess.

This is interesting because it's in an area that A) I would have not intentionally had on and B) am not familiar with yet so I would not have looked there as a cause. I have inadvertantly touched a 'switch' turning it on or off in obvious places and the 'buttons' are not as definitive as I'd like. A color would be better than some vague shade of gray.
 
Agreed. Back to square 1 for your monitor sends, make sure everything's dry and flat, then go from there.

Are you familiar with the procedure for "ringing out" monitors? The built-in RTA overlaid on the GEQ is really helpful here.

In case you haven't already seen them, Behringer has a pretty decent series of YouTube videos that explain the basics of running the X Air mixers. I learned a thing or two.

I believe that I had inputs set for pre-eq (or Pre EQ +M). That shouldn't have been the problem, or maybe it was. I might just have my Pre's and Post's a bit jumbled in my brain... The're just not that complicated in theory unless something else was throwing a curve. Yes, I am familiar with both the ringing out and the RTA. But curiously the EQ seemed to have little or no impact on things as I would have expected them to. Perhaps I am misunderstanding the 'Pre' in the 'Pre EQ' input for this unit. The default is "Post EQ", which is where I intend to leave until I sort all thsi out. That said, my understanding of the Pre or Post EQ is on what would be the channel strip. The 3-4 band PEQ. I then assumed that the GEQ in the monitor AUX is a stand alone apart from this channel strip EQ. With my analog setup thats how I believe it to be. But I think as I write this I am mistaken. The Pre/Post on teh Miz wix was pre or post FADER not pre or post EQ. I am now thinking that by selecting teh Pre EQ input setting is essentially diabled ANY EQ for the AUX's which might explain my symptoms. Maybe?
 
I am now thinking that by selecting teh Pre EQ input setting is essentially diabled ANY EQ for the AUX's which might explain my symptoms. Maybe?
Pre EQ wouldn't disable the EQ on the auxes, but it would send the channel to the bus without your carefully crafted channel EQ settings. It may be part of the problem if you're trying to deal with feedback with channel EQ rather than monitor/bus EQ. Anyway, I think you'd want to select post EQ for your monitor sends. And post fader for FX sends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lakefx and nervous
Pre EQ wouldn't disable the EQ on the auxes, but it would send the channel to the bus without your carefully crafted channel EQ settings. It may be part of the problem if you're trying to deal with feedback with channel EQ rather than monitor/bus EQ. Anyway, I think you'd want to select post EQ for your monitor sends. And post fader for FX sends.
Bummer, and I thought I was on to something. I'd never chase feedback with teh channel EQ though. Once it sounds good in the mains I'd leave that as it is. I'd the chase any feedback with the AUX EQ, normally the GEQ.
 
Bummer, and I thought I was on to something. I'd never chase feedback with teh channel EQ though. Once it sounds good in the mains I'd leave that as it is. I'd the chase any feedback with the AUX EQ, normally the GEQ.
You don't want to chase feedback with the Ch EQ unless it's mains feedback ...
One of the simplest solutions to feedback is to TURN DOWN your monitors and backline - especially if you are putting it all into the PA. Let the PA do it's job ?
Ringing out monitors is one things I DO NOT MISS with going IEM.
Putting a 31-band GEQ on the AUX's will give you more control than a PEQ, as you can notch out the offending frequency.
IIRC - the Buss sends on the XR18 are set to POST-EQ by default.
You "MIGHT" try sending them PRE-EQ and using the buss EQ to solve feedback??
Why? I have found that channel EQ (where one has boosted a specific range) can be the source of the problem. Putting a GEQ on it and notching it will "remove" the EQ you added on the channel (along with all other channels). Can be a catch-22 situation. Or try changing it pre channel until you find the offender and adjust accordingly.. ?
 
Reading through this, I'm convinced that at least a portion of your issues have to do with routing (which a lot of other people have been commenting on). The routing on the X-Air series is not very intuitive even with a lot of DAW experience. I recently had a similar issue where my rehearsal monitors never quite seemed to work the way I wanted. I discovered I was routing to an Aux send when I really wanted to repurpose the busses to be monitors and then route those to individual outputs instead of the mains. That solved all of my issues.

TLDR; Aux and bus sends are not the same thing. Make sure that you are actually routing where you think you are.
 
TLDR; Aux and bus sends are not the same thing. Make sure that you are actually routing where you think you are.
On the XR18 and looking the vid, they ARE the same thing.... but they label them as AUX on the front panel, as AUX "Bus Sends" on the channel sends, but as "Bus 1" (and 2 thru 6) on the app display selection.

But, on the X32 series.. there are separate PHYSICAL AUX and BUS outs on the panel, so there can be confusion there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lakefx
What I mean is that the physical aux sends are not necessarily tied to the aux buses in the software. I had mine routed so that the USB return channels 1&2 were routed to aux out 1&2, which resulted in a slightly delayed master bus mix being sent to the monitors. I had done this when using the X18 as a DAW interface, but forgot about it until the weird monitor behavior. A bus isn't necessarily an aux. Which also means that an aux send isn't necessarily being sent to an aux output.
 
  • Like
Reactions: s0c9

Latest posts