• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Best Prog Rock?

Best Prog Band?

  • Rush

  • Pink Floyd

  • Genesis

  • King Crimson

  • Tool

  • Dream Theatre

  • ELP

  • ELO

  • Yes


Results are only viewable after voting.
Marillion anecdote: I was passing through London in 1983, at loose ends for an evening, so I picked up Time Out (as one did) and scanned for interesting gigs. The listing for the Marquee Club (back when it was in the middle of Soho) showed Marillion, whom I'd never heard of, with the description "Classically influenced rock with dramatic vocals - remember that stuff?", and I though, why, yes, I do remember it and rather liked it. It was essentially the release party for their first LP. I was blown away. While their musical arrangements at the time were often derivative of Genesis, the vocalist, Fish, had some of the best stage presence I've ever seen. I've never seen a crowd clapping along so enthusiastically and accurately for songs in odd time signatures.

They just slayed with "Forgotten Sons", during which Fish popped on a combat helmet, picked up a mic stand, flipped it around to hold it like an assault rifle, and patrolled the stage, working with the lighting to use shadows to good effect. This is video of that song, from a performance later the same year, in a larger venue, not as amazing as the Marquee gig (the mic stand patrol jam gets dragged out, along with the "approach..............friend"), but I'm impressed at how well recorded the audio and video are. The lyrics are quite clear, and brilliant:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Btbp
Colosseum - yet another one of those bands I know of but don't know. And on that To Check Out List. And good - some Marillion, Camel, and other stuff to add just from today's recent posts.

My Marillion anecdotes - I never really got into them more out of lack of exposure, but think I'd like them.

First was years ago on a life-enhancing special experience (long story) at an open air Euro hippy home in the woods party on an island in Thailand with seat cushions and chill music, heard this for the first time. Bought the CD soon as I returned to civilization.

It is a take on Marillion, not entirely Marillion, an intense song and great version of the Marillion original. Like Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis it's something you really have to be in the mood for, as it's got similar goosebump- level super moody harmonic shifts. But added to what was a really cool night with a group of strangers from various countries who met that one time only.


The other is a cool cover (that's Pete Trewavas on bass, of Transatlantic, Kino, others) of XTC's Senses Working Overtime and invited XTC's Dave Gregory and his glorious Rickenbacker 12-string to perform with them.

Sadly the Marillion drummer is no match for XTC's amazing Terry Chambers.

Marillion - Prog; XTC, who I love as dearly as Be Bop Deluxe or Mahogany Rush or Little Feat, etc. - not Prog.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bassmike2010
Colosseum - yet another one of those bands I know of but don't know. And on that To Check Out List. And good - some Marillion, Camel, and other stuff to add just from today's recent posts.



My Marillion anecdotes - I never really got into them more out of lack of exposure, but think I'd like them. First was years ago on a life-relevant special experience (long story) at an open air Euro hippy home in the woods party on an island in Thailand with seat cushions and chill music, heard this for the first time. Bought the CD soon as I returned to civilization.

It is a take on Marillion, not entirely Marillion, an intense song and great version of the Marillion original. Like Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis it's something you really have to be in the mood for, as it's got similar goosebump- level super moody harmonic shifts. But added to what was a really cool night with a group of strangers from various countries who met that one time only.


The other is a cool cover (that's Pete Trewavas on bass, of Transatlantic, Kino, others) of XTC's Senses Working Overtime and invited XTC's Dave Gregory and his glorious Rickenbacker 12-string to perform with them.

Sadly the Marillion drummer is no match for XTC's amazing Terry Chambers.
Marillion - Prog; XTC, who I love as dearly as Be Bop Deluxe or Mahogany Rush or Little Feat, etc. - not Prog.

FYI, Dave Gregory is presently in a proggy/symphonic rock outfit quite beholden to early Genesis, Big Big Train...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Btbp
^^this
And maybe this is the happy medium. They certainly were Prog at some point and made their mark on the Prog world, and unlike many many bands, managed to morph into a different arm of the genre without losing integrity, selling out, or by producing lesser music.

As strong a fan as I am, and I came in at Hemispheres and stopped buying albums after Presto, their Prog run probably started at 2112 and ran up to Signals, after that it was more of intelligent FM Rock music.

I'd argue that Caress of Steel is very prog. I mean, Fountain of Lamneth is a side long epic!
 
Wot, no ELP in a Prog thread? Blasphemy.

Among my top favorites anyway. Classic Lake angelic voice and old school analog synths, to me this song is the epitome of Prog.


Make sure your speakers can handle the bass. And killer work by Palmer.

(the single, not the Welcome Back.... heard on the radio)

Emerson Lake and Palmer oh, yes and Genesis for the most part were the Godfathers of progressive rock and put it on the map.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
You can probably guess my vote. Nothing against any of the other bands (I like most of them) but Rush just rises to the top. Though IMHO if it weren't for the Beatles, there would be no prog.

Yes was my gateway into prog, my parents used to listen to 90125 when that came out. When I started playing bass in the 5th grade orchestra my folks were like, "if you like Yes, check out ELP" and Trilogy just blew my mind. Digging through my dad's vinyl was also how I discovered Jethro Tull and Pink Floyd. And yet, my folks weren't Rush fans, so I didn't even know who they were until high school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doctor Intrepid
Wot, no ELP in a Prog thread? Blasphemy.

Among my top favorites anyway. Classic Lake angelic voice and old school analog synths, to me this song is the epitome of Prog.


Make sure your speakers can handle the bass. And killer work by Palmer.

(the single, not the Welcome Back.... heard on the radio)

They’ve been mentioned 9 times, and were in the poll.
 
I can't believe King Crimson (arguably the originators of prog) are in third place.
Well, it really started as a veiled Rush appreciation thread, in the wake of Peart's death. King Crimson were perhaps the most respected amongst musicians, but they never sold as many records or concert hall seats as Pink Floyd, Yes, or, later, Rush. Personally, I'm surprised that ELP didn't get more votes. Not my personal top prog choice, but they were at least as big as Yes, in their heyday.
And Van der graaf Generator are not even on the list?
I guess that's understandable on this site, since they had no bass player?
Several of us have mentioned them - they were my absolute faves for a few years there - but they were really pretty obscure "back in the day". They *did* have a bass player, sometimes, usually Nic Potter, but it was the bassless quartet that was the best known (and arguably just plain the best) formation.
 
Last edited:
Best shouldn't be reflected in sales.
But yeah, I know it was a Rush love fest to begin with.

VDGG did have a bass player, but Nic was only on two or three albums.
Still Life is my favorite album of theirs.