• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Best Prog Rock?

Best Prog Band?

  • Rush

  • Pink Floyd

  • Genesis

  • King Crimson

  • Tool

  • Dream Theatre

  • ELP

  • ELO

  • Yes


Results are only viewable after voting.
These are at the top of my list:
Pink Floyd
Yes
Rush
Alan Parsons Project
Kansas
Styx
Atlanta Rhythm Section
ELO
Moody Blues
There are others but these are my favorites. :thumbsup:

Atlanta Rhythm Section? Err, wot?

That being said, you did mention the Moody Blues where I don’t think anyone else had. That raises a point, in the realm of barroom arguments along the lines of “first true rock and roll song”, “first metal band”, “first true punk band/album”, and so on. There’s always a tipping point, and some would argue that the Moodies were it, if not actually being the first to represent the genre, before Crimson. Even though not the first to use a Mellotron, they were the ones to bring it to the forefront(of course it helped that MB keyboardist Mike Pinder was involved in the development of it). I personally could see it either way, but I was surprised that they hadn’t been name checked otherwise. The earliest Genesis material(produced by Jonathan King)was under their influence.
THEN...another conspicuous in its absence item would be no mention of German bands(someone did come up with Triumvirat, but I never heard them as being all that original, just ELP wannabes). One band who WAS original was Amon Duul, primarily the second version, but they(and others)get tagged as “krautrock”, which is just lazy thinking. What krautrock means to me is something far more minimal, an actual antithesis to chapter and verse prog. Amon Duul were pretty out there, confrontational, you could sometimes hear strains of Zappa. And speaking of ‘out there’, there’s Tangerine Dream, but once again they get marginalized into not only krautrock, but the separate but equal genre of space rock, where you might find Hawkwind, sometimes even Floyd. But then again, TD was more space than rock.
 
So much of this takes me right back to 1975. One had to be introduced to prog rock albums by ‘professional stoners’ as there was scant airplay of most them. Basements bathed in colored or black lights, Gonesh #2 or #6 incense (I can’t recall exactly). And a killer stereo like a Marantz receiver with Pioneer speakers and turntable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DrMole and Btbp
I put them on the list because Rolling Stone put at least one of their albums in the top 50 Prog Rock albums of all time. Another poster also placed them within the genre.
Yeah, Rolling Stone, their credibility evaporated decades ago. ELO is nothing but the crafty radio friendly pop song acumen of Jeff Lynne, dressed up in the cloak of what the Beatles did with strings on “...Walrus” and “Glass Onion”(in particular), and to a lesser extent, the Moody Blues, and then strip mined into a repeated formula. While there might have been some extended or suite-like passages on their earlier albums, if you strip away all the adornments and production ear candy, it’s actually pretty simple stuff. At best, faux prog; if you listen to The Move during the time he was in the band(toward the end), you’ll find he was basically a meat and potatoes rocker. Roy Wood brought more of any of the classical elements into the band(which would then morph into the ELO concept).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doctor Intrepid
??!!!
Because of your recent Kansas project? I thought for sure of all people you'd put Rush first...
I have been on a bit of a Kansas kick lately but, as much as I love Rush, they really haven't been "progressive" for quite some time. Since... I don't know... Power Windows or Hold Your Fire? Kansas, on the other hand, wrote some symphony grade, progressive rock. Sitting down to learn some of their older stuff reminds me of learning Hemispheres 30-something years ago.
 
I have been on a bit of a Kansas kick lately but, as much as I love Rush, they really haven't been "progressive" for quite some time. Since... I don't know... Power Windows or Hold Your Fire? Kansas, on the other hand, wrote some symphony grade, progressive rock. Sitting down to learn some of their older stuff reminds me of learning Hemispheres 30-something years ago.
I thought of putting Kansas on the list, but I didn't. Upon reflection I probably should have, as well as others to the max of 20.
 
A lot of that American stuff like Kansas and Styx was wannabe-prog. It just had this layer of cheese on it that couldn't click with me.
Agree but Utopia and Spock's Beard are two among other American acts that certainly do rank.

Crack The Sky and early The Tubes maybe not so much but in the Minor league, Starcastle deserve Honourable Mention.

Also, nobody mentioned Klaatu, which is somewhat tragic.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: fretlessguy
I put them on the list because Rolling Stone put at least one of their albums in the top 50 Prog Rock albums of all time..
That's actually a good reason not to.

Although RS started out great and radical (I had hard copies of the first few years of their publications and they really pioneered new ground back then) by the mid-70s they devolved to music's Entertainment Tonight or USA Today.

Also, RS were famously and arrogantly anti-Prog, and, narrowly campy with who they promoted. Their credibility for Prog is and was sorely lacking.
 
Last edited:
Prog isn't about being best, it's about taking the music as far as it will go.

Modern stuff to check out:

The Dear Hunter
Bent Knee
Wilderun
Tonbruket
Opeth
Panzerballett
Lemming Suicide Myth
Stimpy Lockjaw
Animals as leaders
Instrumental (adj)
Gosta Berlings Saga
Shamblemaths
Seven Impale
etc
etc
Don't forget Grizzly Bear and Field Music.
 
as much as I love Rush, they really haven't been "progressive" for quite some time. Since... I don't know... Power Windows or Hold Your Fire
^^this
And maybe this is the happy medium. They certainly were Prog at some point and made their mark on the Prog world, and unlike many many bands, managed to morph into a different arm of the genre without losing integrity, selling out, or by producing lesser music.

As strong a fan as I am, and I came in at Hemispheres and stopped buying albums after Presto, their Prog run probably started at 2112 and ran up to Signals, after that it was more of intelligent FM Rock music.
 
Last edited:
^^this
And maybe this is the happy medium. They certainly were Prog at some point and made their mark on the Prog world, and unlike many many bands, managed to morph into a different arm of the genre without losing integrity, selling out, or by producing lesser music.

As strong a fan as I am, and I came in at Hemispheres and stopped buying albums after Presto, their Prog run probably started at 2112 and ran up to Signals, after that it was more of intelligent FM Rock music.
Exactly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Btbp and P_Dubby
I'm feeling both cheeky and sad due to the death of Neil Peart. So I will thow up the poll hoping that Rush will get some sympathy votes. They are my favorite and I do think they are the best.

So, what say you all? Best Prog Rock band of all time?

P.S. if your favorite isn't on the list they didn't make it past the first vote. You may like them, but they are not a contender.
so this is a popularity contest not an objective test
 
Isn't it the hip thing nowadays to call it Math Rock?:laugh:

tumblr_pbj20r7IdG1tad247o2_500.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: roccobass