• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Butchering a Pedulla MVP5.

As someone just explained to me in a PM, a good luthier is judged not on his mistakes, but on how well he can cover them up!

I just read this. I am going to throw in my experience:

bolophonic said:
As someone just explained to me in a PM, a brand new luthier is judged not on his mistakes, but on how well he can cover them up!

I thought this thread looked interesting from the title up until I saw the photo with the precious logo chiseled off, but reading that the MM pickup route has been freehanded and is crooked made me so eager read the rest....

Edit: I just saw the results. I am impressed. I am the world's worst luthier. I made a mistake on one of my basses that I have never admitted it to anyone. I like it when people mod a boutique bass.
 
Instruments should be played & enjoyed but with care. If it happens then so be it but neglect of an instrument is the worst. These instruments might go on to last for hundreds of years (like a Stradivarius). Michael pedulla won't be around forever & it might be nice for future generations to allow them some decent specimens of his work (or any builder).
 
Project has been finished!

Go here for the outcome!

A Lean Green Pedulla Machine!
I know, necro-thread, but, thanks. I might be looking at a similar project. This thread w/o images was a bummer. Glad the new thread still lives (w/ images)...

:thumbsup:

(edit)
blah... spoke too soon I saw the 1st couple images, then posted. After that is nothing but red x's... :(...

is there any way you couple re-up a couple images? thanks!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: moonshinegtrs