TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Do any of you guys think it's over the top to limit myself to a period correct color?

I think the lack of control plate is one of the more visible things Jimmy does (along with the modified headstock shape) to make these basses 'his own' versus knock-off's of old Fenders.
Those of us who love these basses actually really like that sort of 'modified look' (i.e., the lack of control plate and headstock that 'suggests' a more vintage look without being a copy) that says 'these are new basses with a lot of Jimmy's design and vibe that are meant to 'suggest' some of the classic basses in what many call the vintage era).
There are plenty of companies out there that will make a bass that looks almost exactly like a Jazz bass if that's what you are looking for.
So, to answer your question, my guess is a control plate is not really on Jimmy's list of options![]()
+1 No offense to the folks out there that may dig this finish, but IMHO it's the worst looking thing I've ever seen.I remember the first time I saw an Antigua in person.
...
preoccuppied with thinking about how this bass made it's way to be the ugliest bass ever made.
Yes.Do any of you guys think it's over the top to limit myself to a period correct color?
+1 to everyone else's thoughts.........a lot of times I look at old 70s basses and wish they were another color.....I have a cool ass spec for an LM5, but I ain't tellin'........Vic's spec is cool too, but I would probably do a black pickguard over the sunburst......I think the root beer color is cool as hell......and I can appreciate Antiqua's look as well.........
Well, since you asked, limiting yourself to an exact period color makes no sense to me whatsoever. It's not like you are refinishing a 76 J Bass. You are getting a new bass that is 'inspired' by the original. While I don't have much use for the 'fancy top' versions of Jimmy's basses (which seems to me to be a big disconnect between the design goals of these basses versus the look of those 1600-type models... pure IMO there), any relatively 'traditional' classic finish looks great to me.
Matching a specific period color seems the extreme of bassists 'talking to themselves'.
IMO, of course.
I wanted to follow up on this a little bit. I totally agree that 'FOR ME' fancy tops on Jimmy's basses just doesn't seem to be a direction I am interested in heading or mixing and matching woods and pickup locations. Of course if that speaks to anyone individually by all means go for it!
That being said I know on occassion Ken has mentioned the standard fingerboards are just fine and while I totally agree. There is a certain vibe that I get from my KBP5 with the nitro finish, DN board, burst finish, vintage bridge and a set of flats. It might even be imagined but again 'FOR ME' it just adds to the 60s vibe. When I pick up that bass it looks, feels and sounds like what it is.
My thinking on going blocks and bindings on the LM5 says 70s vibe and that is why I am first inclinded to use one of the period correct colors, although I think I am moving beyond that. That way when I look at it I want to pick it up and be inspired to play with that feeling in my head.
Again 'FOR ME' a basic LM5 just looks like any other modern Jazz bass (a great one of course) but it doesn't scream 70s J until you plug it in and play it (I am guessing as I've never played one). There is nothing wrong with that and from a dollar and cents stand point the Basic LM5 is an unbelievable value, I was suprised when Jimmy quoted me.
I am pretty sure that I took the time to weigh the additional cost of a Deluxe, given the fact that it won't sound any different, but creates a vibe. The reason that I want an LM5 is to help me create that vibe, just like when I stuff a rag under the strings on my KBP5 to play motown tunes, it feels right and sounds right and puts a big smile on my face regardless of who else notices.
As for being utilitarian my LG5 with the slightly brighter Honduran board is more then enough to cover anything I want to do. The other stuff is just fun and cool and I realize I'm a pretty lucky guy...
Thanks for all the guidance guys!
It's kinda funny, but if all else is equal, then I would choose from a period-correct color. Even with Jimmy's updated features (lack of control plate and altered headstock design), his work is obviously a big tip of the cap towards the vintage work that Fender did, and in a lot of ways, I think it would be cool to see a modern version of a vintage-looking (and more importantly, vintage-sounding!) instrument.
Of course, the crux of that argument is that you don't prefer a non-period-correct color. If you want trans purple with yellow stripes or some other modern styling, I'd do that in a heartbeat as opposed to limiting yourself to early Fender colors. But you've stated that you typically think of color as an afterthought, so in that case, why not get a color that's as vintage as the sound and feel?
All I know is that my LG4 in surf green with blocks and binding will look just great, no matter if It's period correct.. which I think It may be btw hihih![]()
I think the lack of control plate is one of the more visible things Jimmy does (along with the modified headstock shape) to make these basses 'his own' versus knock-off's of old Fenders.
Those of us who love these basses actually really like that sort of 'modified look' (i.e., the lack of control plate and headstock that 'suggests' a more vintage look without being a copy) that says 'these are new basses with a lot of Jimmy's design and vibe that are meant to 'suggest' some of the classic basses in what many call the vintage era).
There are plenty of companies out there that will make a bass that looks almost exactly like a Jazz bass if that's what you are looking for.
So, to answer your question, my guess is a control plate is not really on Jimmy's list of options![]()
Jimmy has 6 basses for sale on the "in stock" page!!
I would kina like a fancy top Coppolo like this.
Dan
Or this one
![]()
I am sure I could live with one of the colors offered in the period. What color sounds the best?
My only other idea may be to get either Burgundy mist or sonic blue and base my decision on what sex our first child turns out to be. My wife is due Sept 1
Jimmy seems to be hot on Trans wine, I bet that would turn out really nice too
Yes, I forgot to mentioin trans white in the color discussion. I had a '79 hardtail (non trem) strat in trans white. That was a great guitar and cool color.
-Jimmy