TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Very much so!
now that i loathe 19mm spacing, im curious. what about it is the appeal. is it just the extra room when thumping or is it fingerstyle too?
im glad i like 17.5 because that new 2 band stingray 5 classic is looking fantastic.
Ham hands!![]()
You guys are wimps. I played a Fodera for years that I believe was 20mm at the bridge, and almost 2" at the nut. Now THAT was a bit of a handful.
I again just like the idea of a '4 string plus 1' versus a totally different feeling instrument, since I can go through an entire gig not playing the B string at all in some contexts.

im seriously considering putting hipshot a's on my old fenders because i dont like the wide spacing![]()
now that i loathe 19mm spacing, im curious. what about it is the appeal. is it just the extra room when thumping or is it fingerstyle too?
im glad i like 17.5 because that new 2 band stingray 5 classic is looking fantastic.
For me it matters for fingerstyle as well. I have really big hands and I play much more clean both fingerstyle and slap on a bass with 19mm. Wider spacing gives me more room to vary my attack for when I really want to dig in and get the meat of my fingers on the string. The Fender I'm playing is 18mm, and I've owned a few Smiths which were also 18mm...I can play on those, but 19 is way more comfy for me. Anything 17.5 (like the Stingray 5's) is virtually unplayable for me. I can see the advantage of narrower spacing if you're playing fast lines and/or chords, but I basically just play quarter notes on the 1 and 3 so I can appreciate a little wiggle room.
Walnut?
Aj
I like the 19mm spacing
I don't like the control plates; they're "too much like everyone else"
I can do 19mm to 16.5mm, I don't care much.![]()
![]()
Makes sense,,,,I can't think of another high end "fender" guy copping the early 80's walnut theme.
Do they have Walnut fingerboards?
Aj
probably for good reasoni remember around 10 years ago when walnut late 70's j's consistently brought in less money on the bay than just about any other color.