IMO, so many of the 'fancy top' J basses (Sadowsky and other brands) just don't seem to work, especially basses with otherwise 'vintage' components like burst finishes or tort guards, etc.
Bluesy's bass is truly "drool worthy" and I used to be more to that side the same as you Ken, but, have now come around to quilts and flames with gaurds and burst finishes, there are so many that just look a-m-a-z-i-n-g IMO!
I guess the other side of the argument is "why would you want to cover ANY of that quilt up?

