TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Yes, of course, but as I also said, with Roger's eval policy, this is a moot point, because that policy is specifically in place for this purpose.
I played this axe during a visit to the Sadowsky shop last month, and it does indeed sound like a lively piece of alder - in fact, I thought it was alder at the time. This bass also sounds and plays great! My visit was oriented toward exploring various J-configurations, with which I don't have much experience, but I started and ended with this axe so as to calibrate relative to the Metro R5-24 that I own, but did not have on hand. As much as I liked all of the basses I played that day - especially the Will Lee instruments - I walked out of there thinking about how much I dig the sound of the soapbar-configured basses. This instrument was delightful, and if inclined to order an NYC modern, I'd definitely consider this wood.
I'm gonna guess that sales with this wood will be slow until we start to see reports about how this wood sounds and holds up in the field. Personally, I'd like to know if this wood is more susceptible to dings or dents than alder or ash.

Merry Christmas everyone! Here is a pic of my new black pickguard i got last night! I like it!
I like the black and white knobs more now that I have the B/W/B guard on.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Merry Christmas everyone! Here is a pic of my new black pickguard i got last night! I like it!
I like the black and white knobs more now that I have the B/W/B guard on.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
I'm guessing that if paulownia had an attractive grain like ash then we'd know about it already.![]()
I think I disagree, based on a goodle image search:
http://www.google.com/images?hl=en&...=UTF-8&source=og&sa=N&tab=wi&biw=1280&bih=610
P. Bass said:A pic from chef's link:
Looks a lot like ash. There was also mention in a post on that link that talks about this wood being like any other, in that the grade of the wood basically determines the sound it produces.
B.
Well, to each their own of course, but I've never needed more for this kind of up front go/no-go decision... especially if one plans accordingly to include a gig.As I have explained, the 7 day evaluation period isn't always enough, so it is not a moot point.
Well, to each their own of course, but I've never needed more for this kind of up front go/no-go decision... especially if one plans accordingly to include a gig.
Anything requiring more time than that would be the kind of more subtle thing that could happen even with very familiar stuff, and there's really no way to anticipate that stuff anyway (IMHO).
So maybe not 100.00% moot, but pretty close for all practical purposes for most people with a decent amount of playing experience, I would think.
I don't mean that in a bad way... it's just that, I've found after you've been at it for a while, you get really fast at picking out all the most important points to figure out whether something is worth the purchase for the extended run... while the potential for flip is still there, the risk is small enough that the purchase still makes sense.
Just MHO/IME tho.
As I have explained, the 7 day evaluation period isn't always enough, so it is not a moot point.
but you cannot expect a maker to be able to do more than we do in that regard....
Roger

You may discover after a few weeks or months that the bass is not "the one" for you, but you cannot expect a maker to be able to do more than we do in that regard....
Roger
Sadowsky said:You won't get 7 days if you buy from a Music Store or an individual....
Granted, you may discover after a few weeks or months that the bass is not "the one" for you, but you cannot expect a maker to be able to do more than we do in that regard....
Roger
+1You won't get 7 days if you buy from a Music Store or an individual....
Granted, you may discover after a few weeks or months that the bass is not "the one" for you, but you cannot expect a maker to be able to do more than we do in that regard....
Roger
You won't get 7 days if you buy from a Music Store or an individual....
Granted, you may discover after a few weeks or months that the bass is not "the one" for you, but you cannot expect a maker to be able to do more than we do in that regard....
Roger