• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

do we still need

I'm happy with my 1200 watt bedroom rig.
IMG_0334.JPG
 
Precisely WHERE, did I not make 'spaces?" I proofread, and make sure I've formed sentences correctly, and didn't use profanity. There are commas, periods, and new paragraphs.. if I omit something, well, my bad.
So, please, educate me (space) point out my errors and I'll edit.
[/QUOTE]
Maybe it's my device, but I see no spaces, and a long post with no spaces is tedious to read.

But maybe it's just me, I donno. :)
 
Maybe it's my device, but I see no spaces, and a long post with no spaces is tedious to read.

But maybe it's just me, I donno. :)[/QUOTE]

I'm not sure why there are no spaces in your view- I can assure you, I do my best to make things readable... even with my 'quirks.'
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcnach
First, it’s not at all okay to be telling folks what they should fine with, unless you are signing their check and part of your requirements for the gig is “no big tube amps”.

Well, that all I have. Nothing second….

I think you’ve gone a little over the top with that response.

The OP was just asking the question, not preaching dogma, holding himself out to be some sort of expert, or telling anyone what they should be doing from what I can see.
 
"enlighten me"

real talk what works for one musical situation may not work for another. an SWR WM15 being pushed to be heard in a punk band is not going to offer a tone that suits a modern R&B gig, and vice versa. More wattage equals more tonal options. sort of obvious really.
Yep, I like clean, punchy tone.

In my situation, a 115 at 100 watts would sound like a wet fart. I use a GK Legacy 1200 with a Berg HDN 212 and a volume knob to taste...

No thanks.
 
so something i've been pondering for a while on here and i'm pretty young 33 here but...

i've seen a lot of nah you need 5000 watt tube rig for a bar gig with a drummer and x or xx guitars

real talk i was in a well known seattle punk band for a year on keys and the bass player had a 100W SWR 115 combo in a 2 git, drummer, 3 vox, and me on keys lol so with todays tech and everything being mic'd FOH i/anyone should be fine with a 350W head and 2x10 or am i just the dumb kid and need to get off ya lawn? enlighten me
There was a time when 50 watts were enough. Pete Townshend asked Jim Marshall to make him a 100w head, to cut through the screaming from the women in the audiences.
 
I went from a biamped 500 watt trace elliot into 1x15 + 4x10 (about 250lbs) to a 200 watt trace into a single 12+10 Schroeder (about 70lbs) to a trace Elf into an ampeg 210 av (about 25lbs?) and haven't looked back.

Of course, my bands got quieter and PA systems got better during that progression, AND I got better at dialing in a tone that works in a band setting.
 
i'm pretty young 33 here but...

I'm 22, and I firmly think no.
Some people will defend the 8x10 till the end and I could care less.
Yeah it is a case by case thing
But people who claim you need this big amp for blah blah
It is dumb to be because a small venue for example let's say a bar would not need a big giant amp, if you are pretty much always playing there, you wouldn't even need FOH depending on the room of course. Most medium-to large places and restaurants or bars that specialize in music or live music should have an FOH or hire someone to help them understand it.

While I do enjoy the amazing advice I got on amps, many are hardcore on what works and just like anything on the internet people will generalized. I say most light and small stuff can work. Some on here can be unhelpful with their opinions but many can be. I ain't got against anyone for their tube, giant amp but I am sorry what works for me is what works end of story, thank you. Have a good one.
 
I think you’ve gone a little over the top with that response.

The OP was just asking the question, not preaching dogma, holding himself out to be some sort of expert, or telling anyone what they should be doing from what I can see.
I really can’t disagree there.

(Not what you were expecting, right?….:D)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 75Ric
i looked everything said its a bass cab
I googled "Genz Benz G flex 212" and everything came up guitar cab,

150-watts btw.

Edit to add: seems only GC Used site often lists this as a bass cab, probably because it isn't an open-back cab... I guess I can understand the mistake in that case. :)
 
Last edited:
so with todays tech and everything being mic'd FOH i/anyone should be fine with a 350W head and 2x10

I agree that for any gig with full PA and "everything being mic'd" you don't need an enormous bass rig...but fwiw I've been to an awful lot of rehearsals, jam sessions, and club gigs where only the vocals are going through the PA, where unless there is an atypically sensetive drummer and guitarist, you'd better bring the big guns, 'cuz a tiny combo amp just ain't gonna cut it. Musicians can be idiots.
 
I agree that for any gig with full PA and "everything being mic'd" you don't need an enormous bass rig...but fwiw I've been to an awful lot of rehearsals, jam sessions, and club gigs where only the vocals are going through the PA, where unless there is an atypically sensetive drummer and guitarist, you'd better bring the big guns, 'cuz a tiny combo amp just ain't gonna cut it. Musicians can be idiots.
This.

...and not all PA's are suitable for good bass tone, the one our band uses is not and most clubs we play have inadequate systems.

I prefer to be prepared. Again, plenty of power and a volume knob.