Definitely, to each his own. I have two 4H Specials with flats, and I find the tone is pretty girthy if you play nearer the neck. That's especially true of the 4H with a rosewood fretboard. I've played it in my Motown band and it works fine.
My Amethyst Sparkle 5H Custom wears flats and it’s the one I use for old school Motown , 70’s Soul , as well as Disco . The rosewood/ flats/ and playing technique all make a big difference.Agreed. The stingray pickup sounds nothing like a jazz bass bridge pickup. It can get very very close, or in some cases even better and more smooth (because of the Eq) than a P Bass, especially with flats, of course. You don’t even have to play that close to the neck, maybe just barely past the pickup before it starts to get much deeper. I tend to play my stingray just over the top edge of the pick up.
Sounds very different from my maple / rounds StingRays.

