Do you guys reckon that these Player basses (both P and J) would benefit a pickup upgrade? I’m thinking of putting Aguilar 4J-HC pickups (humcancelling) in my Jazz, to get rid of the hum when not with both pups full on... and to enhance its sound.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I popped an Original ‘62 in my P and Pure Vintage ‘74s in my J, and am really happy with both choices.Do you guys reckon that these Player basses (both P and J) would benefit a pickup upgrade? I’m thinking of putting Aguilar 4J-HC pickups (humcancelling) in my Jazz, to get rid of the hum when not with both pups full on... and to enhance its sound.
Which tuners did you get?I’m sure it would but I decided mine sounded great as is. I bought new tuners though the ordinals are terrible.
I actually think the stock pick ups are pretty good I bought some PV63s but someone said they didn’t notice a huge difference. Do you think there was a bit improvement with the bridge and pickup upgrade?I turned my player into a beast with some upgrades. Put in a fralin. Changed tuners to gotoh resolites. Changed bridge to fender american vintage. Changed knobs to am vintage style.
pots and switches to cts and switchcraft with labella flats. Spent about $300 total. Incredible bass
View attachment 3796938
Just picked up a buttercream J today! Looks and feels beautiful, although I think I may be on the worse end of QC issues. There's a pretty noticeable gap in the bridge pickup and it came with a loose screw in the neck pickup. Besides that, looks and feels really nice. Have yet to plug it into an amp or audio interface, sadly.

Congrats on the new axe. That buttercream would look killer with a black pickguard.
Too bad about the issues, but so long as the loose screw can be tightened, it seems mostly cosmetic.
I actually think the stock pick ups are pretty good I bought some PV63s but someone said they didn’t notice a huge difference. Do you think there was a bit improvement with the bridge and pickup upgrade?
I had the Aguilar 4J-HC pickups in another Jazz Bass. They are good pickups! I sold the bass for other reasons ..pickups were great thoughDo you guys reckon that these Player basses (both P and J) would benefit a pickup upgrade? I’m thinking of putting Aguilar 4J-HC pickups (humcancelling) in my Jazz, to get rid of the hum when not with both pups full on... and to enhance its sound.
That Roasted neck looks awesome!View attachment 3570117 So here it is, just needs a truss rod adjustment.
I had the Aguilar 4J-HC pickups in another Jazz Bass. They are good pickups! I sold the bass for other reasons ..pickups were great though
Nice!thanks! Nevermind though... since then I’ve ordered a 5 string Maruszczyk Elwood with Aguilar 5J-HC... hasn’t arrived yet!
Just picked up a buttercream J today! Looks and feels beautiful, although I think I may be on the worse end of QC issues. There's a pretty noticeable gap in the bridge pickup and it came with a loose screw in the neck pickup. Besides that, looks and feels really nice. Have yet to plug it into an amp or audio interface, sadly.
Love the Buttercreams. And no offense, but IMO, that is one color that I think looks perfect with a white pickguard. I love black or tort guards; but on this particular bass, white looks killer. White Pearl would also be good.Congrats on the new axe. That buttercream would look killer with a black pickguard.![]()
Nice Bass! Not knocking it but what did you gain with swapping vintage MIM with vintage American bridge? Just curious as they are not that much differentI turned my player into a beast with some upgrades. Put in a fralin. Changed tuners to gotoh resolites. Changed bridge to fender american vintage. Changed knobs to am vintage style.
pots and switches to cts and switchcraft with labella flats. Spent about $300 total. Incredible bass
View attachment 3796938
I agree!Love the Buttercreams. And no offense, but IMO, that is one color that I think looks perfect with a white pickguard. I love black or tort guards; but on this particular bass, white looks killer. White Pearl would also be good.
I have a MIJ E-Series ('84-'87) P-Bass in Vintage White. Very similar to the current Buttercreams. One of my very favorite basses; and one I'll never sell (unless I'm no longer capable of playing)...
View attachment 3892377
I picked up a 2018 tide pool. The electronics too me are the biggest let down.Do you guys reckon that these Player basses (both P and J) would benefit a pickup upgrade? I’m thinking of putting Aguilar 4J-HC pickups (humcancelling) in my Jazz, to get rid of the hum when not with both pups full on... and to enhance its sound.
Nice Bass! Not knocking it but what did you gain with swapping vintage MIM with vintage American bridge? Just curious as they are not that much different