• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Flats Decision for a Precision...

Which flats would you use on a rosewood P with quarter pounders?

  • Rotosound sm77 (40-100)

    Votes: 25 23.8%
  • Chromes (45-100)

    Votes: 59 56.2%
  • DR Legends (45-105)

    Votes: 21 20.0%

  • Total voters
    105
I think that you will find that the same strings have varied tone qualities on different basses. So, IMHO, it pretty much depends both on the bass and the tone you seek.

FWIW, I've ran the full gamut of flatwound strings on multiple basses (and have 5x one gallon bags of strings to do it again if needed) - some basses like chromes, others like TI's/LaBella's/77's/Legends, Precision Flats, etc.

I'm using Chromes on one P and TI's on another. GHS Precision Flats are a bit too dark for me - but if I was looking for a "dark" string, that's where I'd go. LaBella's (IMHO) take too long to break in (but last almost forever) - though I do use a mix of LaBellas to get the feel/tension/gauge that I want on one bass. 77's weren't the tone I was looking for - neither were Pyramids.

However, Chromes have just a touch of treble that can be dialed down with the tone control - but the sound still cuts through. TI's however have great mids and lows and are lower tension.

Again IMHO, the quality/quantity of mids is where good flats shine. Pretty much all of them have various levels of initial brightness and solid lows after they are broken in. Each though has different flavors of mids that are either desirable or not.

Long story short, welcome to your tone search.

John

As always, the above is IMHO and YMMV.

John’s response is probably the most honest answer you’re going to get.
You’re just going to have to try a set of strings and determine if you like them.

A few years ago, I ran the gauntlet with round wound strings for all of my basses.
I posted a thread on TB and received several recommendations.
But in the end, each bass has a different set of strings installed, which brings out the best tone of each instrument.

And three of my basses are built to the same specs, but with different pickup configurations.
Each bass has different brand strings.

Good luck in your search.
 
Chromes are very versatile if you still want some brightness similar to a round wound string. If you like some brightness in the tone and strings that you can slap and still get a great sound these are great. They mellow with age, as do all strings...but these tend to fall more into the classic flat wound sound after you play them a while. Depending on the gauge and scale length of your bass you might think these are really tight, but with the proper gauge and setup they can be super easy to play.

LaBella 760F are the classic P-bass flatwound sound that was used by James Jamerson, Duck Dunn, and others. Various gauges and options, such as through body or not. The LTFFs are similar but more flexible. The tone knob can really warm these strings up. Great strings... perhaps the strings that all other flats should be compared with!

GHS Precision Flats are really cool strings. They are not as smooth to the touch as Chromes or LaBellas. That said, the construction is excellent and the outer wrap is super tight. They get a dark woody sound with still some brightness but that wears away quickly. They are similar in tone to LaBella 760s but a bit more low mids and not as much highs. Once the brightness wears off they really sound like a one trick pony, meaning the tone knob or active EQ isn’t going to give you much of a different sound, but the sound is a very good one.

DR Legends are similar to GHS but more of a smoother finish to the outer wrap. They are really high tension like some of the heavier gauges in the aforementioned strings, which is unusual for DR since they are normally very soft and flexible. I have tried these a few times and personally don’t like them as much as the others I mentioned.

I’ve never used Rotosounds, but I probably tried them on another bass. Given how great the other options are I’d probably stay away, but that’s just my personal opinion.

Thomastik strings are great, but not like the others. The low strings are not as smooth to the touch, the outer wrap isn’t completely flat. Very popular with some players...personally I love their upright strings but like Chromes, LaBellas, or GHS better for my personal needs. I may eventually try them again, but they didn’t do it for me the first time.
 
I've had experience with Rotos, chromes, and La Bellas on my 76 P.

Rotos were stiff, but not as stiff as La Bellas and gave a decent thump. Overall very average string, good all rounder. I've come to find they shine when played with a pick. Bending is easy with them. They are kind of "meh" in terms of low end, nothing special. If you don;t boost your lows, you will feel a big loss in low end compared of other flats. They don't break in very fast, so if you are recording, go rotos. Rate 7/10

La Bellas gave my neck a heart attack, and was the best sounding flat I've heard. I would consider them again if they weren't impossible to play fast with (.105 set with action set to 5/64th of an inch). They are great for anything EXCEPT for genres like hard rock and metal that require a lot of hammer-ons. They broke in pretty fast so if you want that Jamerson sound quickly, they are your go to. Over they do a great job filling the bottom end in any mix where other flats and rounds don't. They are amazing when lows are boosted and played fingerstyle with the tone rolled off. Obviously sound great when dead, just listen to any Jamerson recording .Rate 8/10

I had chromes on there as well, but only for a short period before putting rounds on. They were pretty bendy and easy to play with normal gauge and action (6/64ths on an inch .105 set). They were the smoothest flat texture wise, which is nice if you are going for an upright sound and feel. I don't remember much of them, but they sound great especially when dead. Tons of low end on those bad boys and I might go back to them if I don't find a super bendy flat by La Bella to put on my MJT 60's P that's coming in a couple of weeks.

Hope this helps.
 
Thanks for the insight everyone! Ideally, I'm just looking for the best overall set for rock, pop, blues, roots and jazz. I don't need a super bright tone for what I play.

Also, string prices are nuts here in Canada...so I'm just sticking to these 3
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
I'm just looking for the best overall set for rock, pop, blues, roots and jazz. I don't need a super bright tone for what I play.

Of the three you listed, the D'A Chromes are the most "middle-of-the-road" suited for the widest range of styles. So, you should start there.

Then if you decide you want to go more "old school", try the DR Legends; if you want to go brighter, then the Rotos.
 
Using Rotosound 45/105 flats, i am happy with them, they sound bright but also stiff. They dont sell 50/105 Chromes or Labella flats here thats why i went for rotosound by the way. Both of those strings getting really positive feedbacks so far.
 

Latest posts