There are different schools of thought on the matter. This one says that they may hear the pitch just fine, they just cannot replicate it.I, like others, stuggle with the definition of tone deafness. I have a son-in-law who is a genius with things electro-mechanical and loves music. He spent middle school and high school playing saxophone in the school bands and helps a friend DJing parties. But when he tried to "pick-up" bass guitar (I don't think he really tried to learn), he couldn't get very far at all! I tried very hard to teach him, but he couldn't/wouldn't remember squat! And, when he thinks he's "singing" it's like nails (of any kind, lots of them!) on a chalkboard!
I think he's tone deaf. Yet his mother swears he always made As in band class. Yet there's no known incident or injury since then to explain now.
I dunno.
.
Invalid Link Removed
I have found that I can sing some songs quite well, and others terribly. Or maybe I just think I sing some well?



, but I found a photo of real Gibson Girls (and some Gibson Guys, including Lloyd Loar).


