No it doesn't because the instant that a drummer and other live musiciansd come into the equation, your metronome lessons are immediately invalidated. Scales and other exercises are really bad practice principles to use with a metronome. In fact, they are totally ineffective, but I know that some will not believe this.
That's why you have to learn how to do both. Playing with a metronome and learning how to place the beat in different ways is, IMO, invaluable for when you encounter a drummer. Now, if you made metronome practice the end-all-be-all of rythmic training, then yes I could see how you would be ill-prepared for the give and take that comes from all musicians time sense. I also find it extremely challenging to play scales/chord-tones using whole notes while set to about 30-60 bpm. Also, I like to set up the metronome to drop out for several bars so that I can try to keep time in between.
That being said, there IS NO SUBSTITUTE for playing live with others. Agree 100% with you here. I think the first year or so of me gigging full time eclipsed several years of bedroom study. IME of course.
Yes it is! Still, I hold to the idea trhat practicing for a career is an ineffectual way to learn. I regard very strongly practicing as preparing to be a player and regard gigs as a fringe benefit that comes when I am deserving enough to acquire those jobs.
Realize that just about every great bassist who records with a click didn't develop this skill with a metronome. If this is so, one would have to ask themselves where their skill of click playing came from.
Not a bad philosophy, but only one of a myriad of approaches IMO. If a up and coming player is dead set on working in hip/hop or rap, than IME working with an MPC drum machine is INVALUABLE practice, just as your approach to studying music is to me a logical way to learn how to improvise within a Jazz context and also to master the fretboard. You might see the first approach as limiting, but that only makes sense within the parameters of your particular, and well thought out, musical approach. When I am trying to propel a swing groove on a jazz gig, the last thing I'm thinking about is metronomic time per se. I alter my approach to fit the playing of the rest of the band. However, when I"m asked to lay down some bass alongside a drum-machine, I HEAVILY lean on my skills of playing around a click track.
You are a gentleman and your questions are intelligent and thoughtful. Consider that most professional musicians have way more skills than just playing in time to a click. These skills come when one is deep into musical improvement and the rewards come when one is truly dedicated to music and the regard of it.
True, and thanks for the compliment. I'm curious to know how developing the skill to play consistently along with a click track is any different than playing with a metronome and/or drum-machine/sequencer? And yes, this is only one of MANY abilities that a professional MUST have.
Thanks for taking the time for this discussion!