• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is it ok to quit over text message?

Status
Not open for further replies.
You can do whatever you want.

For me, I'd man up and tell them face to face. That it's time to move on is fine, but you made money and several friendships with them over a four year period, and even though we're deep into The New Normal, stepping up and doing the right thing never changes.
 
ya know my business idea of firing people could work both ways..I would provide a service to do resignations too..avoid the messy break up, avoid the "aww cmon stay for awhile" rhetoric, avoid the whole situation and i will step in and the band will feel as though they have been given a gift, it will be so heartfelt that some may even cry..I'll even throw in a pep talk to keep them playing and not fold up as a bonus...

If there is money involved such as part ownership of PA equip, or lights n stuff I will mediate that scenario as well...this is a full service
 
Reminds me of Paul Simon’s 50 Ways to Leave Your Lover.
The singer called and said to load the truck for a gig.
So I drove to the practice studio in my truck, loaded my PA and my large bass rig by myself but nobody else showed up.
Then he called again and said no gig. Gonna have band practice instead. Unload the truck and we will be there to practice.
Since everything was already loaded I put ‘er in gear and split.
See Ya Later Alligator!
Never went back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bumperbass
I've been with this band 4 years. 6-piece classic rock outfit. I'm just ready to move on. It's gotten a bit stale and i have original music I would like to promote next year.
We had a few gigs even during covid but the drummer (bandleader more or less) is having surgery. No gigs or rehearsals till January. Our lead singer is 64 and not in great health. I don't know how much longer he'll be up to gigging.
We don't really socialize together but the drummer and guitar player have been generous in various ways.

They have told me before that if I quit, they would fold the band for good. "We could do it without you, but it wouldn't be fun without you."

I don't have to quit. I know promoting my own music will not be a money making venture and I could use the cover band money to pay original music band members. I just don't know if I'll feel like spreading my time so thin. I'm in another cover band that just started up again after a few years off.

Anyway I don't feel like calling up each of the band members individually to tell them I'm leaving, but a text message seems pretty impersonal. What do you think?

Are you quitting or rage quitting?
 
I did it last May . It's not the more stylish way to do it but I had my reasons to do it that way

Basically our singer had selfish behaviours which affected me and I understood that he wont change for anybody so I decided to go my way. I could keep it inside for more time and due the Covid sutiation we couldn't figure out when we may make an appointment for a band meeting. I sacrificed the expected manners for my wellness and I don't regret about it.

One of the guitar players waited until the band could meet again to tell them that we was leaving too . I didn't want wait that long.
 
due the Covid sutiation we couldn't figure out when we may make an appointment for a band meeting.

Exactly, due to Covid I sure can't do this in person. The band has always communicated via group text. One of us doesn't even have email so I seriously doubt we could do a zoom call.

Anyway I'm really shocked that some of you would take quitting via text so personally! Sending a nice message about how I got to move on to other things, love you guys though, etc etc, was never meant to be a disrespectful move.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seanto
This thread was an interesting read. The people who mentioned that there's not really any reason for you to officially quit are onto something. You've described a situation which is either coming to an end or at least slowing down significantly. Given that the gigs with this band will be few and far between, why not just work on your original stuff anyway? If the band does start up again and you feel the urge to quit, you can cross that bridge when you come to it.

That said, if you wanna quit regardless, I really don't think anyone here can tell you what's right because you know the band dynamic better than we do. I've been in about 15 bands, and each situation was unique. I quit some bands thinking that the in-person way was appropriate only to have some band members get pissed because they felt they wasted their time (and gas money) to get to the rehearsal space just to have me quit. I called the last guy I fired, and he was so petty/childish that it devolved into a ridiculous "conversation" -- really, just him making s*** up for nearly an hour. I had a feeling it'd go that way, and I wanted to just email him. Wish I had because I think it would've been better for both of us.

This opinion might not be popular, but I think too many people treat bands like marriages, and unless it's everyone's full-time gig which pays the bills, I don't see the point of making a big to-do about quitting. Sounds like the band you're talking about is a hobby cover band. Absolutely nothing wrong with that -- that's my current band situation -- and it's just not that serious. I've had a few personnel changes (people leaving and me letting people go), including someone who quit via text. Didn't bother me at all.

You just have to do what feels right to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass and equill
This is the part of bands I have never understood. Nothing is happening with the band until January, but does that mean you can’t do your own thing now? Will the other members be mad at you if you play with another project?
I come from a jazz background where you play all kinds of gigs with various people all the time. You might have a main band that comes first, but everyone plays whatever gig they can get.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barrenelly
I've been with this band 4 years. 6-piece classic rock outfit. I'm just ready to move on. It's gotten a bit stale and i have original music I would like to promote next year.
We had a few gigs even during covid but the drummer (bandleader more or less) is having surgery. No gigs or rehearsals till January. Our lead singer is 64 and not in great health. I don't know how much longer he'll be up to gigging.
We don't really socialize together but the drummer and guitar player have been generous in various ways.

They have told me before that if I quit, they would fold the band for good. "We could do it without you, but it wouldn't be fun without you."

I don't have to quit. I know promoting my own music will not be a money making venture and I could use the cover band money to pay original music band members. I just don't know if I'll feel like spreading my time so thin. I'm in another cover band that just started up again after a few years off.

Anyway I don't feel like calling up each of the band members individually to tell them I'm leaving, but a text message seems pretty impersonal. What do you think?

If it's people you get along with and like, even if you don't consider them full-fat 'friends', I'd say they deserve something a bit more direct and personal. I'd be disappointed in their place if I got a simple text.

The drummer in one of the bands I'm in recently quit. He's getting busier in other things and he decided music was getting in the way, no drama. We don't see each other much besides gigs and occasional rehearsals (it's a RATM tribute band, so the songs are already written and we know them -we've been at it for years), guitarist lives out of town, etc. So our drummer used a group chat to let us know what he was thinking. It was still 'by text' but it wasn't a simple dry text and bye. It was more... a chat. He told us about his concerns etc, and that he has decided that he doesn't have the time for the band anymore. We exchanged a few messages etc, and it was quite alright. So it can be done, but if you do it by text maybe approach it like a group conversation and not simply tell them you quit and disappear, you know what I mean?
 
I've been with this band 4 years. 6-piece classic rock outfit. I'm just ready to move on. It's gotten a bit stale and i have original music I would like to promote next year.
We had a few gigs even during covid but the drummer (bandleader more or less) is having surgery. No gigs or rehearsals till January. Our lead singer is 64 and not in great health. I don't know how much longer he'll be up to gigging.
We don't really socialize together but the drummer and guitar player have been generous in various ways.

They have told me before that if I quit, they would fold the band for good. "We could do it without you, but it wouldn't be fun without you."

I don't have to quit. I know promoting my own music will not be a money making venture and I could use the cover band money to pay original music band members. I just don't know if I'll feel like spreading my time so thin. I'm in another cover band that just started up again after a few years off.

Anyway I don't feel like calling up each of the band members individually to tell them I'm leaving, but a text message seems pretty impersonal. What do you think?

Why not discuss this at a band meeting?
 
Exactly, due to Covid I sure can't do this in person. The band has always communicated via group text. One of us doesn't even have email so I seriously doubt we could do a zoom call.

Anyway I'm really shocked that some of you would take quitting via text so personally! Sending a nice message about how I got to move on to other things, love you guys though, etc etc, was never meant to be a disrespectful move.
You were with the band for four years and can’t be bothered to make five phone calls and you’re surprised people are calling you on it? That’s the risk you take when you ask for people’s opinions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: buldog5151bass
I guess I suck. I resigned by email. Really didn’t want to talk to the BL to be honest.
I fired a drummer by email once. He had been acting like a Richard Cranium for a while and we almost came to blows in our last rehearsal. I realized later that he was just too much of a puss to quit so he pushed my buttons until I fired him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.