• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is my friend a bad person?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't exactly announce the arrival of every little piece of bass equipment that comes through my door, but then again, I probably average less than $30-40 a month in expenses for my only real hobby, which is modding the basses I already own and I've pretty much run out of things I need.

Smuggling in three complete basses after losing my job and then posting about it like a joke would be a red flag to myself that maybe I had some underlying issues with honesty and hoarding and respect for my wife.
 
Well, then you obviously need to Google "irony". Or perhaps "ironie" if that makes more sense in duch than english as the consept of joking obviously is new to you....
I grew up speaking Commonwealth English, so I even know the difference between irony and sarcasm. Maybe my sense of humour is just drier than you're used to.
Which joke do you think I missed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tari
I would say this says a lot more about their relationship than it does about him in this situation. I did that in my last marriage. I would squirrel money away here and there and get stuff. Now, i wouldn't hide it, but I also knew that she wouldn't know one piece of gear from another. I just never had the conversation. Now, as you could figure from me calling it my "last marriage" that it ended in divorce. Was it because of the music gear thing? No way. Not even a little bit. It had everything to do with the way we dealt with each other that led to this sort of behavior. We were living separate lives under one roof. Almost never on the same page. Usually feeling like were working alone in the marriage. ....and at enough times working against each other.

My current marriage, we work together. I don't hide anything. I don't lead a second, super-secret gear hording life. I still get gear from time to time. I have a side stash of money but she's fully aware of it. She knows I am not dumb and if we need the money for something that takes priority, it's there.

Again, I think this speaks more to his relationship than anything.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: equill
I grew up speaking Commonwealth English, so I even know the difference between irony and sarcasm. Maybe my sense of humour is just drier than you're used to.
Which joke do you think I missed?
All of them? You are obviously a much better person than the rest of us in here, at least much better than me and the guys having fun. You can be proud of your self. :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: DrMole
In his defense, Bob is 61 and was on the verge of retirement anyway. Money is not really an issue and the bass was a very inexpensive Squier Mini P. He just for some reason felt a bit guilty and didn't want to explain why he was buying another bass. He also didn't want to not buy the bass.
That changes a lot to the story. Squier mini P is at least in the same ballpark as getting some work done on the bass. Also if money is not an issue, anything sub 200 $ might just be the same as buying a new pair of boots and some jeans. Wifey doesn't need to be informed about everything upfront. But there is also no reason not to tell her :D Bob obviously knows all the details and at age 61 he would be perfectly fit to make his own judgement. It was a funny read so thank Bob from me will ya?
 
Here we go again, asking marital advice on a bass forum. Too many people on here who "won't pass judgement." You are in complete denial, " I didn't mean to do it." You must be kidding me, you took a freakin empty case with you and the only possible intent was to lie to your soon to be ex-wife.

Plus 1minus the ex-wife part.

There a million different ways people run their relationships and if it works for them, it's ok with me. Even though I for the most part wouldn't want a relationship like theirs.
So if Bob's marriage works happily like that, Bob is not bad.
He just slyly sneaked around saying "I want a mini P bass so bad." And standing for it.

I was married twice and found it useful to run a Three-bank-account model.
Any money coming in from jobs goes to bank account 1. This is where all the normal living bills are payed from (rent/mortage, car(s), insurance, food, furniture etc.).
Then there's an agreed-upon sum that goes to bank accounts 2 (hers) and 3 (mine).
This agreed upon sum in my case was
Total income
- total cost of living
÷ 2, so each got the same.
We also agreed on having our own rooms.

So whatever one liked to buy for him or herself was a personal decision not to be questioned as long as it fitted in that personal budget and room.
My wife pointed out, this was a solution to my disadvantage, since I had more money-consuming hobbies than she had.
I said: "Well then, go and work more hours so more money is coming in."
Which she did.

I wanted it that way, because my parent's marriage suffered (amongst other things) from my dad spending a lot of money (some he didn't have) on "his stuff" and my mum was implicitely expected to make up for this by running the house at minimum cost.

Anyway, I am divorced now for other reasons but wouldn't want a relationship with "secrets" like that.
Basically I do not want to keep anything worth mentioning secret from my partner.
But that's just me.

On the other hand, my wife was absolutely tolerant if not ignorant to my gear acquistions.
For example she marveled at the black 12string Ric 330 I brought from a US business trip:
"It's sooooooooo stylish and beautyful".
She also liked the sound.

Not that she was that much into music, at least not all music.
I had a hardrock day one November sunday going from Jeff Beck Group to Deep Purple, Led Zeppelin etc.
After some hours she came to my room because of something else and on leaving asked: "Say, not that I mind but is there any specific reason why do you listen to the same record all day?"
I loved that women, in a way I still do.

Final remark: I guess Bob's wife knows about his secrets.
She just doesn't mention them unless she feels it is necessary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: El Thumpo
So my friend - I'll call him Bob - told his wife yesterday that he had to take one of his basses down to the shop to have some work done on it. Then he took an empty bass case, kissed her goodbye, loaded the case into his car's trunk and headed to the store.
At the store Bob tried out a bass he was interested in and discovered he really liked it. Bob had cash on him that he had taken from a hidden spot in his garage where he puts money from gigs and stuff he sells, so he paid for the bass, asked the store to set it up etc and told them he would pick it up the next day. Then he went home and just left the empty case in his trunk.
The next day Bob went back to the store to pick up his new bass, put it in the case, went home and told his wife he was going to go to his music room to test out the repaired bass. After a little test - just a few hours - the new bass just slipped into the collection with his other dozen or so basses.
Bob says he really didn't intend to deceive anyone... it just happened. Is this normal behavior, or is my friend a bad person?
Bob is an idiot who's tempting fate.

Marriage is based on compromise and honesty; if the money was his, he shouldn't have needed to hide it, and if he wanted to buy a bass with it, he should have had an honest discussion with his wife.

Ask yourself this: If your wife finds out that you're a liar and divorces you, how many basses do you have left after the dust settles?
 
  • Like
Reactions: chadds and equill
I don't have to deal with "humanity". I have to deal with individuals. If I know, or strongly suspect, you are a liar, then you are an individual for whom I have no use.

Agree. While it's instructive to look at things from both a global perspective and in the abstract, human action is specific and involves interacting with local realities. 'Humans' are real. 'Humanity' is a mental abstraction.
 
Bob is doing it wrong. There is a better way. It is always easier to get forgiveness that it is to get permission. When my wife was alive and I found a new bass or amp or whatever, I just brought it home and showed it to her. Sometimes she would ask why I need another one. We should all know how to handle that question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRA
Bob says he really didn't intend to deceive anyone... it just happened. Is this normal behavior, or is my friend a bad person?

It's probably been brought up, but he most certainly intended to deceive someone. One doesn't just put an empty case in one's car, with the intent of slipping it by the person he allegedly loves more than anyone else in the world, accidently.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.