I just picked up a black and maple Japanese Geddy Lee which I'll post a NBD once I finish modifying/fixing it, and I hafta partially agree: My personal preference:
You are picking between three bass3s - three different quality levels and prices, blind, and price is your only deciding factor?
I looked at the 40th anniversary Squiers. I change my vote to seafoam. But folks seem to like those 40th basses. Excited to see what ya get!
In general I like classic looks, white, black, aged (ivory, parchment, mint green), natural wood (including certain sunbursts). My first choice is the black/white Fender Player. I already have a white/mint Player precision (that I had no trouble choosing). I included the black Squier Affinity because it’s 1/3 the price and plays and sounds fine. The Player precision is my mainstay. The Squier sunburst, part of the new 40th Anniversary series, is oddly intriguing and unusual but unpopular and not much discussed. I describe it as antique, solemn and dignified.
Your best bet is to play them first because how the play and sound is more important than how they look.
They all sound similar, they’re pretty much the same bass. The Fender Player might have a barely audible added depth and richness to the tone, and possibly other details that can come to light with time and use. But I’m not a professional, Squiers are excellent instruments, and I already have a Player precision (and a Squier CV 50s single coil p bass, and Epiphone Embassy).
The comments definitely lean that way, but the vote is evenly split, with the «ugly» burst leading. Looks like people are ashamed to say so .
If you like all the colors but can't play them in person... go with the one that seems like its in the best condition, has the straightest neck, doesn't have a stripped truss rod nut, and weighs less than 9 lbs.