• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

MLB 2025

Who to root for? Hope this list by my friend Brand Stanhope helps. Go Mariners!

Feel free to use the list to prioritize your teams during the postseason, which starts Tuesday.
1. Mariners. Have never won a title or even qualified for the World Series. Charming team.
2. Brewers. Have never won a World Series. Smaller-market team.
3. Guardians. Roared back from way, way behind. Haven't won a title since 1948. I still call them the Indians.
4. Reds. They're playing the Dodgers first.
5. Tigers. Cool old-school uniforms. Also, I played for the South Bay Tigers in Little League.
6. Padres. Should be lower, but it's hard to hate them. They're kind of the Giants' rival cousin. Battle them, but cheer for them if you can't do something.
7. Phillies. They're a fun team. Once I start watching them, they may move up the list.
8. Blue Jays. I often forget they're a team.
9-10. Cubs and Red Sox. Teams that somehow became synonomous with "tortured fan bases," even though their fans are no more tortured than Mariners or Brewers or (pre-2010) Giants fans. They just have a lot of writers who like them and constantly beat us over the head with them.
11-50. Vacant
51. Yankees. Still the Evil Empire.
52-1,000,000. Vacant.
1,000,001. Dodgers. I guess there's a way you could root for them . . . no, there's not.
OK, that's pretty good. My only quibbles are: 1. The Cubs have only won one title in the past 100+ years, the Sawx (and the Giants) have three! Plus the Mariners have been around for a relatively short 48 years. 2. The Padres have Machado, so boooooo!
 
  • Like
Reactions: slobake and MCF
Early 2010’s wasn’t exactly the best time for being an M’s fan, except for getting to see King Felix and Ichiro do their thing. I guess it was the 2010 season when Felix won the Cy Young award despite the team having like 100 losses 🤣
He was barely a winning pitcher when he won the Cy Young. That just shows how good he was and how awful the teams were. 2001, when the Mariners steamrolled the regular season, they flamed out without a whimper in the playoffs. I hope they get farther than one round this time. Getting past two rounds means the World Series. I plan to be absolutely insufferable if the Mariners win the World Series. At least until next season when it will be their year again. Until it isn't.
 
I could go for a Mariners/Brewers World Series, Brewers in 4 (it would be good for my blood pressure not to go any further). You have the Yankees too high.
It would be a good matchup, but the outcome would be the other way around. Really. You read it here first. Probably in seven. Mitch Garver will finally earn his keep by hitting a walk-off in the bottom of the nineth in the seventh game in front of an empty stadium. The fans of both teams will all be long since dead from massive heart attacks.
 
He was barely a winning pitcher when he won the Cy Young. That just shows how good he was and how awful the teams were. 2001, when the Mariners steamrolled the regular season, they flamed out without a whimper in the playoffs. I hope they get farther than one round this time. Getting past two rounds means the World Series. I plan to be absolutely insufferable if the Mariners win the World Series. At least until next season when it will be their year again. Until it isn't.
You PLAN to be??



:hyper:
 
It would be a good matchup, but the outcome would be the other way around. Really. You read it here first. Probably in seven. Mitch Garver will finally earn his keep by hitting a walk-off in the bottom of the nineth in the seventh game in front of an empty stadium. The fans of both teams will all be long since dead from massive heart attacks.
A walk-off in Game 7 would be a Brewer walk-off, so I'm good with that. I'm not sure if I can take the stress leading up to it, though.
 
Good on the Reds for giving it a go against the Dodgers. They scored a decent number of runs on them. Unfortunately the Dodgers were able to score twice as many runs off Reds' pitching 😅 LA is now game planning for their series with Philly. Smart of them to finish up the Wild Card series as quickly as possible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCF
Today's starting pitcher match-ups according to MLB.com.

1759419711531.png


I think all these guys are going to be on short leashes today! Not a lot of really great pitchers in the mix here. It's sad to see how poorly Yu Darvish has pitched this year. But he's 38 years old and been around a long time now. His starts were appointment viewing during his years with Texas. So good.

Boston and New York both have rookies taking the hill. Combined they've made less than 20 big league starts. Early is 23 years old and Schlittler is 24. Can't help but wonder if the lights will be just a little too bright for them in the postseason. It will be a great learning experience for them regardless of the results. It will be a great story if one of them pitches well and factors into a long postseason run for their team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCF and GregC
Today's starting pitcher match-ups according to MLB.com.

View attachment 7335125

I think all these guys are going to be on short leashes today! Not a lot of really great pitchers in the mix here. It's sad to see how poorly Yu Darvish has pitched this year. But he's 38 years old and been around a long time now. His starts were appointment viewing during his years with Texas. So good.

Boston and New York both have rookies taking the hill. Combined they've made less than 20 big league starts. Early is 23 years old and Schlittler is 24. Can't help but wonder if the lights will be just a little too bright for them in the postseason. It will be a great learning experience for them regardless of the results. It will be a great story if one of them pitches well and factors into a long postseason run for their team.

Good summary.

In all cases, these pitchers are the #3s on their respective staffs. You're a #3 because you CAN be good sometimes but you are not always good...otherwise you'd be a #1. Thus, as in almost all baseball games at all levels, the games will hinge on the specific performances of these pitchers.

And...

The games will hinge on the managerial decisions on when to pull them, what matchups work or don't work for their bullpens and the timing thereof. We saw that with Aaron Boone pulling Max Fried too early the other day and with Craig Counsel leaving Imanaga in too long yesterday. That's why they make the big bucks....

Gonna be some good baseball today...enjoy it everyone.

.
 
I'm hoping the Cubs' bats wake up today! They're due after scoring 3 and 0. Hopefully they can get to Yu early. Taillon is pretty solid for a 3rd starter, but as noted above he's not the most consistent.
Of the guys going today, I'd probably feel most confident about Taillon giving his team a quality start. Most of his September starts were solid performances. The issue for the Cubs, like you say, is the lineup isn't giving their pitchers enough run support. In one game in September against the Reds, Taillon gave the team 7 innings with only 1 run allowed... And the Cubs lost that game 1-0 😬 😂 Sadly, going up against Darvish could be the cure the Cubs' batters need. He's basically a "five and dive" guy at best this season, typically with 3 or 4 earned runs allowed. I would absolutely love it if he could be vintage Yu Darvish just one more time today, because he's so fun to watch when he's got all his pitches working. I don't know if it's in the cards though.
 

Latest posts