• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New Fender Antigua models...

I think that is the appeal....I've never liked them either....but the more I see them the more I want one....not because they look pretty but because they don't....crap, I hope I don't buy one.

See? That's what I was saying also! I looked at them for the first time and they made me a little squeamish....but the more I looked, the more I liked!

Ordered one (P-Bass) yesterday and damn glad I did!
 
Oh No! I am starting to think the same thing. Fender is playing some mind control game on us.
I think that is the appeal....I've never liked them either....but the more I see them the more I want one....not because they look pretty but because they don't....crap, I hope I don't buy one.
 
Those e-bay ones really have a greenish hue to them. The original Antigua finish is just gorgeous, I have a 1967 Fender Coronado II in Antigua, and it's a cream colored hue with brown edges, no green in it at all. Nobody that's seen it has ever been able to avoid falling in love with it.

Fender is protecting the value of the original finish by going a bit different route, but it's less attractive than the original, for sure. I'd still rock one, if I didn't have 13 bass guitars already!
 
I think the P-bass looks more authentic. A bit too light maple though (they should have used some tinted finish to make them look more vintage). Is the 9.5 radius notably too flat if you're used to 7.25, or is the difference just negligible?
(I have a 78 P with 7.25 radius which is my favorite curvature.)
 
They're only overpriced if they don't sell.

Did you by chance hear of the recent crash of the housing market that has been going on for about the last 5 years? I understand market pressures and all, but there is a case to be made for actual value vs. inflated prices. There may be forces (GAS for one) that drive people to buy at a price that exceeds value.

In any case, as to whether or not they manage to hold their value, this is a question that each buyer will have to suss out if it even matters to them.
 
I think the P-bass looks more authentic. A bit too light maple though (they should have used some tinted finish to make them look more vintage). Is the 9.5 radius notably too flat if you're used to 7.25, or is the difference just negligible?
(I have a 78 P with 7.25 radius which is my favorite curvature.)

IMO, the difference is noticeable but not great. I prefer 7.25" boards also.