• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New found respect for John Paul Jones.

bullshark

bullshark

Sep 7, 2006
791
409
Montreal, Canada
floatingby.com
#1
Always liked Led Zep as a band but I've never really been that attentive to JPJ work as a bassist in that band. Don't know why, really, t'was just like that. Maybe because he never had that exuberant flashiness displayed by the other members?

Until I tried my hand at playing The Lemon Song. Wow. Serious groove in there, and no two bars played exactly alike throughout the song. A serious display of musicianship.

I must say, I'm not going to be so quick to dismiss any fellow bassist work from now on, keeping my ears open instead of going by assumption, I might just learn more this way.
 
#4
hmm! i always thought he was the strongest musician in that band! and they were no slouches.
yeah the lemon song was a knuckle buster for me too, it's keeping the momentum even and consistant that's a bitch.
 
#10
Mine is the opposite view. I never paid attentionto JPJ because the band's music was so bad. Page is an annoying lead guitarists- sloppy soloing without the benefit if passion. Plant's voice is even more annoying. The wrote very few songs- because a riff ain't a song. And if the song can't stand up without the specific performance, it ain't a good song. The best Page solo ever is the little one he composed for "Whole Lotta Love". It's just a cultural phenomena, but the music just wasnt' there for me.

But reading Jones' interviews in GP and later in BP made me pay attention to his playing. Now if he and Bonzo had hooked up with a real songwriter like Townsend, and a real rock 'n' roll singer like Paul Rogers, that'd have been a great band.

jte
 
#11
Oh god. I don't know what to say. There's probably no point trying. I will say that JPJ would strongly disagree and he'd be right.
Also, it sounds like you're saying YOU can't play Zeppelin and do it justice. That's not their problem or an indication of bad songwriting. Any good song can be butchered.
JTE said:
Mine is the opposite view. I never paid attentionto JPJ because the band's music was so bad. Page is an annoying lead guitarists- sloppy soloing without the benefit if passion. Plant's voice is even more annoying. The wrote very few songs- because a riff ain't a song. And if the song can't stand up without the specific performance, it ain't a good song. The best Page solo ever is the little one he composed for "Whole Lotta Love". It's just a cultural phenomena, but the music just wasnt' there for me.

But reading Jones' interviews in GP and later in BP made me pay attention to his playing. Now if he and Bonzo had hooked up with a real songwriter like Townsend, and a real rock 'n' roll singer like Paul Rogers, that'd have been a great band.

jte
Click to expand...
 
#13
Im tired of people saying that Jimmy page was a sloppy playe, my lord cant people getit throught their heads, that is his style and it is greatly incorporated on Zepellin's sound so stop batching a great band w/great musicians, and well Robert Plant had a distinctive voice very raspy yet able to manage to do highs kind of like a soul man..
 
#14
JTE said:
Mine is the opposite view. I never paid attentionto JPJ because the band's music was so bad. Page is an annoying lead guitarists- sloppy soloing without the benefit if passion. Plant's voice is even more annoying. The wrote very few songs- because a riff ain't a song. And if the song can't stand up without the specific performance, it ain't a good song. The best Page solo ever is the little one he composed for "Whole Lotta Love". It's just a cultural phenomena, but the music just wasnt' there for me.

But reading Jones' interviews in GP and later in BP made me pay attention to his playing. Now if he and Bonzo had hooked up with a real songwriter like Townsend, and a real rock 'n' roll singer like Paul Rogers, that'd have been a great band.

jte
Click to expand...


Hmmm... All this time I thought I was the only one. I always loved the JPJ and Bonzo but never got into the other two. I've played just about every popular Zep song over the years. I love playing them! But listening to the rest of the song usually gets on my nerves. And as far as not-so-clean playing (Jimmy Page) being a "style" gimme a break. I'm not saying that there are no redeeming qualities to the guy's playing, but it's not like he COULD play clean and CHOSE NOT to because he liked the style.
 
#15
+1 and I'll go one more. Anyone who doesn't at least acknowledge Jimmy Page as an excellent guitar player is an ignoramus. BTW, I've never met a competent guitar player who so foolishly dismisses Page - only bass players who give the rest of us a bad name. And BTW, Zep/Page wrote many fabulous songs.
Lalo said:
Im tired of people saying that Jimmy page was a sloppy playe, my lord cant people getit throught their heads, that is his style and it is greatly incorporated on Zepellin's sound so stop batching a great band w/great musicians, and well Robert Plant had a distinctive voice very raspy yet able to manage to do highs kind of like a soul man..
Click to expand...
 
#16
Ah, well these are the responese I expected. I don't dislike Zep as I dislike hair-metal, Nirvana, and contemporary country artists. It's just that I don't think the MUSIC is as good as the band's place in pop culture would reflect. I don't mind sloppy playing if it's passionate (I like Neil Young), but you gotta bring something to the table and Page AS A SOLOIST is lacking in passion, techinique, and frequently interesting ideas.

As a producer, and as an orchestrator of guitars he's great. Layering lots of rhythm guitars, getting specific sounds out of different isntruments and blending them together, and then getting them to come out of little home stereo speakers- he's great!!! Getting Bonzo's drum sounds on vinyl is genius.

The comment about performance relates to the live recordings I've heard over the last 30+ years. The SONGS don't hold up without that specific performance. The original four memebers playing the songs live is what I'm talking about.

YMMV, and the point wasn't really to dis Zep, even knowing it was gonna come off that way. It was to point out that Jone's obvious musicianship got lost FOR ME in the things about Page and Plant that drove me away from Zep's music. So even though I've been paying attention to them since my buddy Phil played the brand new Led Zepplin II record for me decades ago, I never knew what a great bassist Jones was. The annoying breathless affectation from Plant and then his banshee scream along with the stupid lyrics of "What Is and What Should Never Be" kept me from appreciating the great bass work there.

jte
 
#17
Bassgrinder77 said:
+1 and I'll go one more. Anyone who doesn't at least acknowledge Jimmy Page as an excellent guitar player is an ignoramus. BTW, I've never met a competent guitar player who so foolishly dismisses Page - only bass players who give the rest of us a bad name. And BTW, Zep/Page wrote many fabulous songs.
Click to expand...

Well, I know a lot of guitarist who put Page into the "Recognition deserving bigger talent" category.

Many fabulous songs? OK, give me some SONGS that have lyrics and music that both make sense and can stand alone from the production and performance. Can you reinterpret the song without having to play it just like the record and the song is still fabulous? That's what a SONG is- the essecne boiled down away from who played what.

jte
 
#20
I said competent guitarists.
Songs? The first 5 albums, from Good Times Bad Times to The Ocean. Lyrics? I won't wade into that. Any lyric could be quoted and subjected to criticism.
Re songs, your argument doesn't hold up.
There are lots of great songs who's original recorded performance is so unique and strong that a reinterpretation won't work in most listeners ears. That's no condemnation of the song, it's a commendation of the original performance.
JTE said:
Well, I know a lot of guitarist who put Page into the "Recognition deserving bigger talent" category.

Many fabulous songs? OK, give me some SONGS that have lyrics and music that both make sense and can stand alone from the production and performance. Can you reinterpret the song without having to play it just like the record and the song is still fabulous? That's what a SONG is- the essecne boiled down away from who played what.

jte
Click to expand...
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back