But remember, back then the playoff pairings didn't require you to fight your way out of your own Division/Conference. The top 16 teams in the entire NHL standings made the playoffs. Then the seeds were #1 vs. #16; 2 vs. 15; etc. So the shorter-than-7 games formula seemed a little more fair. It was rare for a #16 to upset a #1. But of course when you got deeper into the seedings (ie, 8 vs. 9, etc.) the teams were more evenly matched. Nevertheless, I always liked that 1 vs. 16, etc. format.
These teams already play their Division rivals so often in the regular season. And the old way, if the final two teams left standing happen to be from the same Division or Conference, so be it. I liked it.
I have no problem with Taylor Hall's suggestion though. That would shorten the regular season a bit. The NHL regular season combined with the playoffs has to be the most grueling of any sport, IMO.