• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Paul McCartney

Status
Not open for further replies.
Everyone needs to open an ear a listen! Years ago, I hated the beatles! until bout 2 years ago, I started listening to them! Paul is so melodic with overplaying! What ever kind of music you play just need to keep an open ear, and learn from all kinds of music it will make you a better player!
Take Care
TravellinMan
 
Behind perhaps the 2 fenders, the stingray, and the Rickenbacker, what would be the most recognized bass ever (and I'm talking about forever)? It would have to be the Hofner. Why? Macca played it.(and I'm sure Rickenbacker should thank him he is also - as if everyone who has ever seen the Walrus clip from Magical Mystery Tour didn't make themselves a promise that they would one day own that bass).
He may not be Stanley Clarke (my other hero), but he is certainly still very capable on the instrument. He was indeed a true innovator on the instrument.

I don't see a problem with him reversing the order of the Beatles songwriting credits, as it has been pionted out, it was that way originally. I don't see what Yoko's problem is. They are his songs.It is not like he is ommitting John lennon's name. Everyone knows that they pretty much stopped collaborating after Hard Day's Night anyway. What bugs me is this - Yoko a couple of years ago claimed that she had a hand in writing Imagine!?! I find this more offensive than any of McCartney's actions.

Also, it is true that first and foremost a song-writer. It is the same sort of thing with Zappa, who said he was not a guitar player, but a composer that happens to operate a guitar. I read an interview on some online bass magazine with McCartney, and he said that if he was stranded on an island, it would be a guitar he would take with him, not the bass. He realises that the bass is just support, although his lines (in The Beatles especially) do stand out - they were not meant to be the lead, that is what Georgie-boy was for.

By the way, the Beatles being the most over-rated band.? I've got to agree with most and say that the Stones , in my opinion, fall into that category. Start Me Up is really the only song that, if it comes on the radio, i don't switch the station.
 
fellas, I should have read my last post before submitting - 'he is' should have been deleted from the Rick sentence.
Also, when I say bass was just support, please do not emphasise the JUST. I hope i have not offended anybody. I know I have 'though. I even offended myself.
Lastly, I still cannot get over the overrated belief that one or two have. Even with all the exposure the band has, I still consider them to be one of the most underrated bands!
When the Hell will they release a remastered catalogue?? My cds are sounding crap. It may be the stereo?
 
I was pretty sure some of their stuff was remastered I know we got all new mixes at the radio station I worked at a year or two ago. I think the only reason I believe the beatles are overrated is no group could ever live up to their hype and I just have always preferred their songs when someone else (ray charles, joe cocker, tina turner, gov't mule) was playing them. I don't really see an issue with him switching his name with John I doubt there is a person in the world who looked at that and thought less of John.
 
what makes me like Mccartney is that he seems to have so fun when he is on the stage and acting.

To me it seems that he was born with that bass in his hands.

If you look at him playing with the Beatles he is the fellow who moves a lot on the stage. And always with a smile on his face.

He really is one with the Bass.And he playes it like it was a guitarr
 
Flatwounds says "What bugs me is this - Yoko a couple of years ago claimed that she had a hand in writing Imagine!?! I find this more offensive than any of McCartney's acti"


In point of fact, not that this has anything to do with bass playing, Yoko Ono published a book called "Grapefruit" in about 1968 that contained a lot of the lyrics to "Imagine". She actually wrote a lot of the couplets for the song and thye whole thing was laid out like 'imagine_____, it's_____' with different things filling in the spaces. John mentioned it in one of his last interviews. Not that the tune was inconsequential in it's success, nor that I'm a huge fan of Yoko's music (though I note that she has the #1 dance single in the Billboard Charts this week. Who would have ever predicted that?), but that's the deal.

Personally, I think the concept of the bass being a "support" instrument (even if it was a mis-quote) is something we could all stand to explore.
 
Yes, it's actually true, Yoko did contribute to Imagine. I read a quote from John somewhere saying that Imagine was really a Lennon-Ono composition, even though it was only credited to John.

Personally, I'm actually not a huge fan of that song. It's been voted at the top of polls for a long time, I think - but I can't say I really like it *that* much. IMHO, it's very much inferior to what John did with The Beatles.
 
Paul is a fine musician and bassist. No other bassists played for the song as well as he, except maybe James Jamerson.
I love his lines in Oh Darlin, no new ground but just the right stuff.
He rocks with the best of 'em in Helter Skelter.
I saw some disparaging remarks on Ringo in this thread as well. Ringo came up with some very clever grooves and drum parts. Yeah no flashy rolls and fills just great drum parts. What drummer hasn't copped a Ringo groove? A very underated drummer IMO.

And as far as the Beatles go the CD "No. 1's" is still at the top of the Album charts in billboard after 77 weeks! And they broke up what 30+ years ago?

Peace
 
Although I think Paul is a decent drummer as far as bass players go, I never thought he played with the same authority as Ringo. Ringo never played the flashy drum fills but he had a naturual swing to his playing that grooved a lot better than Paul. I think Paul actually sounded kind of stiff.

Also, John Lennon played bass on Helter Skelter.;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.