• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Phyiscal playing limits...thoughts and ideas?

First off, this kinda goes out to those who might have some sort of physical limits when it comes to playing. Second, I’ve been playing an electrical instrument since I was about 16, now 34. It started with guitar but like a lot of us bass guys I bet, there was a lot of guitar players already. Plus after hearing Cliff Burton playing Orion…I was hooked.

Now to my issue….sorta. I was a snot nosed brat at 11 and jumped out of a swing. After a week in the hospital and having a temporary pin put in my elbow. I was left with some problems. My only way to describe it is this. Pick up your instrument, fret on the low side with your index finger on the first fret, and your ring/pinky on the 3rd fret. Well I can’t quite do that 100%. With some maneuvering I can though, but I can’t play that way for long as it tends to start hurting my elbow and wrist. That’s the one thing I loved about my SR800 when I had it, such a thin neck. Now I’m on the BTB400. Basically, I can’t get my palm to face the fret board completely on the low side of the neck. Coming up the fret board it gets easier though. I can’t say it’s hindering my playing that much, but I know it comes into play some times, but I can usually work around it. I know if some trained musician was to watch me play, they would critique me big time, but it’s what I got to do. So here in the past days I’ve been thinking about going up to a 6 string because I thought I could compensate for some of that low E action and play it on the B string. A perfect example of a song that I can have trouble with is Jump in the Fire- Metallica. Nobody would ever know I have this issue and I really never even see it unless I’m playing something like that, so it’s not like I’m deformed in anyway, just limited. So I bet some are thinking why 6 when you can do that with a 5? Well, my musical style is drifting toward that kinda stuff you hear with a 6. I’m not much of a slapper or a picker. I like the finger style stuff way to much. Besides, I kinda feel if I’m going up in string count, make the leap….but not too much :)

So what are your thought, ideas, and comments, gripes bad or good? What about compenstaing the low E action on the B, good idea or bad? I know the SR's have thin necks. I've seen a few posts about widths, but other than the SR's what other companies make or can make thin necked 6 strings?
 
Hey! Nice to see you bassing in the face of adversity :) This issue is not foreign to me either. My roomate was working in a kitchen and put a knife through his hand, severing some tendons. This has left him unable to fret a guitar properly and made it completely painful to play a bass (which is how I got my Kramer so cheap!) for over 10 minutes. He has to do weird arm movements to pull off many of the chords that he does (he is not a bad player at all) and all of his guitars were purchased with the neck being the selling factor.

Ibanez makes nice 5-strings, but I'm going to go ahead and reccomend Cort. A Cort Artisan B5 or A5 has a slender neck with nice low string spacing and is the most comfortable 5-string I've ever played.

As for weather or not that will solve your problem.. you could always string the BTB in BEAD and give it a whirl.
 
I have a similar problem. Due to an injury I can't get my left palm completely parallel to the fretboard. So basically you have to compensate. I use as small a neck as I can find and try to stretch the fingers as much as possible. I may not use textbook correct technique, but I've figured out a method that works.

That's why I don't play guitar. Some chords I just can't manage. The bass is more fun anyway.

Besides, the object is to play the bass and make it sound good. How you actually accomplish that doesn't really matter in my opinion. It may look strange, but if it works for you, go for it.