• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Please explain Zombie

Zombies are second only to politics and religion in logical inconsistencies required to defend a position. Avoid further mental strain trying to right the obvious illegitimacy of "living dead."

It's not that I look to argue its just you can not argue with video media! Dead means you seize function, the one thing the normal process boils down to is the ingesting, filtering and release of waste.

Breathing has nothing to do with it.

Silly answers. Zombie film media popularity exceeds literature by far.

Shame on actors for breathing!
 
It's not that I look to argue its just you can not argue with video media! Dead means you seize function, the one thing the normal process boils down to is the ingesting, filtering and release of waste.

Breathing has nothing to do with it.
The idea that an organism as complex as the human body could function (stand upright, move, hunt, eat, etc) while having complete shutdown of any of its major organ systems is scientifically indefensible.
Brilliant!

BTW, I saw WWZ last night...Liked it...
I was less disappointed than I'd expected to be. Enjoyed Brooks' books and knew going in it would be a deviation from them. Appreciated that they'd stayed somewhat true to his international scope, but PG-13 horror movies rarely satisfy like they should.
 
People yearn for a brutal post-consumerist post-apocalyptic afterworld in which you can tool up and go on guilt-free shooting sprees and loot canned goods.


Err, maybe ;)

I think there is a lot a truth in this. We live in a regulated society, bound by red tape and commissions and laws and whathaveyou. It's easy to feel powerless and insignificant and without personal souvereignty. In a postapocalyptic world, crapsack as it may be, you have to rely on yourself and this scratches people's itch for a sense of agency. You might not make it, but at least it was your life. Your failure. You own that, know what I mean?
The zombies are a way to make that experience into even more of a powertrip, because it's basically a cheatcode: You live in a postapocalyptic world where resources are scarce and everyone essentially is the enemy. Now replace almost all those others with mindless, slow lumbering idiots and you effectively have taken most of your competition out of the equation.

Or alternatively: the zombieflick is popular because it pleases your ego. Think about it; you and your friends are the only sane, rational, caring people around in a sea of unthinking, beastlike creature who may resemble humans, but in fact eat them alive. And your group is always in danger of being overwhelmed by these stupid, base-need driven others. I can see how people might relate to that, though they wouldn't necessarily admit that :D
 
I just saved 10 000$ in psychoanalyst by reading your post St Drogo, thanks !

Accidentally, most zombie flick obey to a set of cinematographic rules, and it's kinda interesting to see different take on the same concepts when you like to analyze movies and how they're made.
 
I think there is a lot a truth in this. We live in a regulated society, bound by red tape and commissions and laws and whathaveyou. It's easy to feel powerless and insignificant and without personal souvereignty. In a postapocalyptic world, crapsack as it may be, you have to rely on yourself and this scratches people's itch for a sense of agency. You might not make it, but at least it was your life. Your failure. You own that, know what I mean?
The zombies are a way to make that experience into even more of a powertrip, because it's basically a cheatcode: You live in a postapocalyptic world where resources are scarce and everyone essentially is the enemy. Now replace almost all those others with mindless, slow lumbering idiots and you effectively have taken most of your competition out of the equation.

Or alternatively: the zombieflick is popular because it pleases your ego. Think about it; you and your friends are the only sane, rational, caring people around in a sea of unthinking, beastlike creature who may resemble humans, but in fact eat them alive. And your group is always in danger of being overwhelmed by these stupid, base-need driven others. I can see how people might relate to that, though they wouldn't necessarily admit that :D

I too have gone through phases of being one of civilization's malcontents.
 
The idea that an organism as complex as the human body could function (stand upright, move, hunt, eat, etc) while having complete shutdown of any of its major organ systems is scientifically indefensible.

I was less disappointed than I'd expected to be. Enjoyed Brooks' books and knew going in it would be a deviation from them. Appreciated that they'd stayed somewhat true to his international scope, but PG-13 horror movies rarely satisfy like they should.

I would call WWZ more of an "action" movie than a real "Horror" movie...which is somewhat disappointing...but it was good all the same...