REDDI vs Countryman Type 85 vs Fender TBP-1
Got a REDDI finally. Ran it in the studio, used a variety of basses closest to hand: my Alembic AXY equipped bass with graphite neck, another self made bass with Alembic Activators (Js), and an Ibanez RB850 with low impedance Ibanez pickups, a stock Rickenbacker 4003; Gotham cables, and NS1000M monitors. No EQ, no compression.
The countryman gives the best articulation of notes and being less bassy in girth the notes are punchier and offers best clarity of the three.
The REDDI retains some of that punch but has a girth in the low end that makes it sound like a mic'ed amp. Back and forth switching with the Countryman, the Type 85 can sound a bit thin on some tracks, but can offer better articulation (aka "cutting through the mix") in some cases. The REDDI is very good though and I agree about the instant gratification, it gives a great 'amp' sound.
The Fender TBP-1 has as much girth as the REDDI but the articulation is lost and a bit sloppy ... I noticed that it was a lot fatter than the preamps I was accustomed to when I first got the Fender, as for years I used either a Demeter VTBP (the old 1.5 U one) or an Alembic F-1X (and still do), which were clean and fat enough to serve as primary recording devices in my studio when I ran it commercially. I still keep those and like them, but I can see the REDDI taking a place in the studio for me.
I will do a live gig tomorrow and can decide whether for live use I can discern that much difference. As a recording device, it may be heresy to some, but it is the tool that gets the job done for a specific task and expense and reputation goes out of the window for me. I can see the REDDI being useful for the bulk of recording situations but coming from the years of using the Demeter and Alembic, it was not that much an epiphany for me, it was a nice surprise to hear the immediate difference to a Countryman.
The big question? Is that subtle difference worth the money? Paid about 800 AUD for it, and would say yes. It is easy to use, and gets you a tone with little set up.
Sorry if I don't share the euphoria some have, it is a great DI, but my bass DI epiphanies was first encountered with the Demeter/Alembic.