• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Roscoe Club

#10,121
@SteveC, IMO and experience, you can make *just about* any P bass sound great with a pickup and string combo you like (I know there are huge differences in quality, but the P sound is unique in that it doesn't require as much tlc, imo, as other pickups). It would be a great way to scratch your itch for a P, not break the bank, and still be happy with the sound and playability.

For example, I rehabbed a garage sale no-name p-bass, refinished the back of the neck and gave it a setup, replaced the bridge, dropped in my favorite P pickup I had (a classic Bart), and installed TI Jazz flats. I'm not saying every cheap bass could turn out this good, but I probably have about about $200 into it at this point, and I have recorded/gigged/enjoyed it immensely. Being from the midwest, I also like explaining what a good deal I got on a very good-playing, great-sounding bass. ;)

I also sanded the red off the headstock, refinished it and had a water slide decal made that says Superbad FUNK BASS. I thought I was clever at the time. This whole thing was also a fun project.

15479178167691616950557562452543.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: staccatogrowl, JOME77 and SteveC
#10,124
Bassworship1 said:
I'm not downing fender as I've drove out of my way hours several hours many times trying to bond and like the Elite's and Deluxe series models. I wouldn't take 2 fenders for 1 Roscoe. I know that's blasphemy to many on here but that's my experiences of them lol.
Click to expand...

Different strokes for different folks. Everyone knows that I love my Roscoe's .... but I'd put my new Fender Elite Precision against any bass that I've owned (playability, overall quality and sound). All Fender's aren't great. But guess what? All Roscoe's and Devon's aren't either. Nor are MTD's, Skjold's, Elricks, Smiths, Zon's ..........
Maybe a Roscoe P and J bass can do the Fender J and P Bass thing as good as a real Fender, but no way that it can do it better than a Fender..... and Fender gives it to you for less $$$.
It doesn't make me love my Roscoe Custom Sig 5 any less. It is what it is!:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TolerancEJ and campbems
#10,125
JOME77 said:
Different strokes for different folks. Everyone knows that I love my Roscoe's .... but I'd put my new Fender Elite Precision against any bass that I've owned (playability, overall quality and sound). All Fender's aren't great. But guess what? All Roscoe's and Devon's aren't either. Nor are MTD's, Skjold's, Elricks, Smiths, Zon's ..........
Maybe a Roscoe P and J bass can do the Fender J and P Bass thing as good as a real Fender, but no way that it can do it better than a Fender..... and Fender gives it to you for less $$$.
It doesn't make me love my Roscoe Custom Sig 5 any less. It is what it is!:)
Click to expand...

I can easily respect that and why I said IMO. Went several times with intentions to buying a Febder Elite or Deluxe, driving 2 hour round trips each time to try stores that had (played roughly 6-7 different times at 2 locations) several to try. All had bad setups from the factory and was just underwhelming for the $2100 price tag. Oh and I’ve never played a bad Roscoe or Devon. Ive also never played a Fender that made me think I wanted it. We are blessed to live in a time where there is an abundance of very good bass choices where anyone can find something to satisfy them.
 
Last edited:
#10,132
SteveC said:
Yeah, hard to believe but I have had this bass for over 6 years now. I may think about something different from time to time, but anything would be an “add” thing, not a sell and replace thing.
Click to expand...

That's a good thing Steve. Sounds like you've found a really good Roscoe and you love it. My experiences have been that if you own 3-4 Roscoe's you still end up just playing the one that really speaks to you. Much better to supplement that one good Roscoe with a nice fretless and a Fender style bass. It took a lot of basses for me to finally get it out of my system but I finally did. I've got what I believe to be the best Roscoe 5 that I've ever owned, a killer Fender Elite P-bass 4 that plays and sound wonderfully and a Warmoth Gecko 5 fretless with a thick ebony finger board coated with polyester (i.e. Pedulla buzz).
That's it for me (unless I drop one coming down the stairs).:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveC
#10,133
Yeah, I have that G&L JB-2 for a passive jazz “Fender” vibe. I have held back but I do know that one of my old Roscoe fretless basses could be available if I were to want it. We’ll see. Maybe a less expensive fretless as I don’t use it quite as much.

If it works for you, it should work for me as well.
 
Last edited:
#10,134
paddydaddyo said:
I am so glad to finally have another LG-3005 after selling my prior one years ago. It is sooooo easy to play, sounds so good, and just makes me want to pick it up and have fun every day ... Can't wait to start gigging with it in a couple months!

Here's a quick vid of me playing along on one of the tunes my band will be doing.

Roscoe basses are the bomb-diggaty.

Click to expand...


Enjoyed this one! So much that I had to play along over your play over. Sure makes it easier learning a tune watching someone else play it.:)
Nice playing by the way.

After 35 years of playing every Sunday at church, I've taken a break (actually started taking the break 2 years ago). It's been nice getting to go to church with my wife and leave when the service is over.:)
At any rate, I didn't realize just how soft I'd gotten until I started playing more of the difficult tunes. I played some really complex Black Gospel when I first started playing church but the 20 years or so we played acoustic led worship (Tomlin, Crowder, Redman, ....) and they didn't push me to hard (musically).
At any rate, I've started playing with a couple local groups that do the classic rock material and it's been a blast playing (and getting my chops back up). We'll probably eventually play some local fairs/festivals but for now it's fun just working the material up.:)
I'm also really enjoying playing with real amps (not IEM's). What a joy!!! :bassist:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: paddydaddyo, mwbonsall and Fred312b
#10,135
JOME77 said:
. . if you own 3-4 Roscoe's you still end up just playing the one that really speaks to you. . It took a lot of basses for me to finally get it out of my system but I finally did. I've got what I believe to be the best Roscoe 5 that I've ever owned. .
Click to expand...
Although one may love vanilla ice cream before venturing into "31 flavors (BR)," a new favorite flavor could emerge with venturing into the unknown. How would you know without tasting many flavors, or tasting new? However, after all of that tasting, it is theoretically possible that vanilla is 'the one and only forever." Good luck with that. .

I propose something different. A new name for Monday could be LG5. Tuesday could be SKB fretless. Continue in this manner and rename each weekday after the Roscoe you play to represent it. Seven different Roscoe basses is recommended for those up and coming contributors to the Roscoe club thread. Keith will be very happy to entertain this idea.

Happy (SteveC's former) Century 5 Standard Plus fretless day!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: steelin4u, JOME77 and SteveC
#10,136
staccatogrowl said:
Although one may love vanilla ice cream before venturing into "31 flavors (BR)," a new favorite flavor could emerge with venturing into the unknown. How would you know without tasting many flavors, or tasting new? However, after all of that tasting, it is theoretically possible that vanilla is 'the one and only forever." Good luck with that. .

I propose something different. A new name for Monday could be LG5. Tuesday could be SKB fretless. Continue in this manner and rename each weekday after the Roscoe you play to represent it. Seven different Roscoe basses is recommended for those up and coming contributors to the Roscoe club thread. Keith will be very happy to entertain this idea.

Happy (SteveC's former) Century 5 Standard Plus fretless day!
Click to expand...

LOL

Fritz you sound so convincing that I'm almost persuaded to ride the merry-go-round one more time!
"Uh! What's that dear? OK. Logging off TB". :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nightman and campbems

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back