You really think Burgatory or BRGR makes a better burger than Wingharts or Five Guys? I've tried all the exotic meat burgers, the steak burgers, the fat medium-cooked ostrich burgers, with their crazy aoli's and candied bacon and whatnot....
But none of them compare to the pure deliciousness that is a fire-grilled Five Guys cow burger. I load that f**ker up with all the toppings they'll offer, 2 or 3 sauces, and a bag of Cajun fries and just let myself go into a coma.
Wingharts, for those non-Pittsburghers out there, is a pretty awesome local whisky bar that makes the BEST charred-outside bloody-inside tasty cow burger I've ever tasted. They have one called the 'Oly Cah' (*pronounced "Holy Cow") thats covered in chipped chopped ham and beer cheese. My mouth is drooling just thinking about it. You'll spend $30 on a burger, fries and a couple bourbons but its worth it to treat yourself every now and then.
The "high end" gourmet burger places take it a step too far... the presentation is nice and the fancy meats are a cool gimmick, but their burgers just dont have the flavor of the lesser 2 establishments... in my opinion YMMV etc. etc.
BRGR seems like it's somewhat halfway between Five Guys and Burgatory in terms of being a gourmet burger place. I still prefer Winghart's to Burgatory, but I still really like Burgatory. The issue with Burgatory is there are so many options, it's easy to combine the wrong toppings and make your burger taste funny. I take the KISS approach to burgers, as I want to be able to taste the meat over everything else.
I'm not sure if I could pick a favorite between Burgatory and Winghart's. When I get the elk burger at Burgatory with the salt and pepper rub, I could probably eat just that without any more toppings. It's fantastic.
Honestly, the best burger I've ever had is still the Gator Burger from the Rathskeller at Penn State.
