• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Shipping Damage: Lost For Words

He's asking for a return. I've only seen pictures of the bass. The claim with reverb has just been filed this morning after I denied a full refund. I argued that this isn't the bass I sent so I asked him to show me the damage and SN in one shot. He declined and said it's in Reverb's hands now. I don't know what to believe. I asked to see pictures of the box. I can tell if the box was opened and repacked. I tape my boxes a weird way. I also keep track on how I restring the bass. I know which ones were string though the body and which weren't.
I don't see how you can have that kind of damage while it was packed inside a hard shell case. Something fishy there.
 
It does look like the same bass to me, and it does appear that that one ding on the lower horn might have already been there. I notice the bass has Dunlop strap lock buttons installed. You didn’t happen to leave the strap locks unsecured, or perhaps ship it with the original strap buttons unsecured did you? To me, it looks like a strap button may have been flying around in that case and at one point was at the bottom of the case and the bass landed on it. In that case it would indeed be shipping damage, and might not be covered since it would be due to bad packaging. Not trying to attack you or say you did anything wrong, just trying to explore all avenues here. Hope everything works out for you, man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: browndog
It does look like the same bass to me, and it does appear that that one ding on the lower horn might have already been there. I notice the bass has Dunlop strap lock buttons installed. You didn’t happen to leave the strap locks unsecured, or perhaps ship it with the original strap buttons unsecured did you? To me, it looks like a strap button may have been flying around in that case and at one point was at the bottom of the case and the bass landed on it. In that case it would indeed be shipping damage, and might not be covered since it would be due to bad packaging. Not trying to attack you or say you did anything wrong, just trying to explore all avenues here. Hope everything works out for you, man.
Yes. the shape of the damage is intriguing. Very good thought here.... and that would demystify everything except the lake of photo with serial number
 
Last edited:
I've only had to ship a high dollar item once and I used UPS. I paid for UPS to pack it but I made a video of the condition of the item I was sending as it sat on the UPS counter and as I was talking to the customer service person. Sorry the OP is going thru this hell. I found recording using my mobile phone and uploading the video to youtube for all to see made the deal good with no blowback.

It looks like the guy dropped it from that gouge on the side. That wouldn't happen in that particular case that looks form fitted to me. Upset with himself he wants to return it.
 
Last edited:
That may be a ding I missed. I’m not sure if that was a ding though. My current strap leaves brown pieces all over the place because I need a new one. If I didn’t dust or blow off the bass before taking that photo then it would look like a ding. I can’t really see it in other pictures at different angles. Now the other dings were not on the bass nor my pictures.
I'm sorry... A ding I missed... I know every ding on all my basses... You make me laugh... :smug:
 
UPS is not my favorite shipping mode. That being said, if there was an inspection needed due to the cost of the instrument, it would have been done while the shipper (seller) was there. That way UPS can ascertain if there is any pre-shipment damage that could come back on them. It looks like the seller is a little south of reputable. It's a shame. I hope it works out for you.
 
I'm sorry... A ding I missed... I know every ding on all my basses... You make me laugh... :smug:
Really! A small spec that you could barely photograph or rub over and feel is not difficult to miss? I take it you haven’t owned many basses? I don’t know every small ding that’s 1x10^-4 mm big. But I won’t miss those big dents that the buyer or someone put in a brand new bass. I honestly care more about the back of the neck on my bass. I can’t stand any dings on the back of the neck

Either way, I’ve sold and bought countless basses on here without any issues. My track record here and on Reverb speaks for itself so you can laugh till the cows come home.
 
vjwqyvrikq34sgg9pb5y-jpg.3591806

Is it coincidence or does the buyer have the same carpet as you have? (bottom right corner of the pic.)
 
My guess is that the buyer bought it, immediately dinged it, panicked, and then came up with the scheme to claim shipping damage and return it. That damage could not have occurred with the bass in the case. The whole idea of a body swap scheme in order to get rid of his previously busted up body is just too complicated to make it worthwhile.

The only other feasible alternative to me is that the seller dinged it up, panicked, and shipped it anyhow, hoping that the buyer would blame it on shipping damage and file an insurance claim. This does not seem likely to me (though that is just based on a gut feeling).

The only thing that might satisfy both parties to some degree would be an insurance claim through the shipper. They take the bass and auction it off, buyer gets his money back, seller keeps his money. I have been on the buyer end of this, but not the seller end, and it was E-Bay 15 years ago, not Reverb today. In my case, the box was clearly damaged, and the case was cracked, as well as the finish at the neck joint (Epi Sheraton). Buyer kept his money, and I got an insurance check from the USPS some months later. However, in the OP's case, I doubt that an inspection of the box and case would prove shipping damaged, unless it was faked by the buyer prior to making the claim.

A Reverb dispute isn't really the solution here, but unfortunately, that's the route the buyer took. Unfortunately, that could go either way. Worst case for the OP, he gets the bass back, resells, and gets screwed out of the diminished value. Hopefully it's just a hundred bucks or two.

Is it coincidence or does the buyer have the same carpet as you have? (bottom right corner of the pic.)

Not much of a coincidence that two people have tan carpet.

I can tell you that the two sets of pix were taken on different cameras.
 
Last edited: